4 ms·
His argument doesn't need a definition of conscience. He argues that if A arises from certain traits of B, then you must accept that A also arises from C, since
by wodenokoto 11y ago
His argument doesn't need a definition of conscience. He argues that if A arises from certain traits of B, then you must accept that A also arises from C, since it contains the same traits.
Secondly he clearly refers to a definition of conscience called phenemonology. And one must assume that "materialist" is a term in philosophy that people familiar with the field knows what entails and people not familiar with it doesn't. this paper is not an introduction to either of those terms.
Your complaint is that you don't know the what these words are and that is what is apparently wrong with philosophy.
- rquantz 11y agoThank you. I'd also like to add that philosophy has a long history of pretty dramatic accomplishments in the real world. You can thank philosophy for science and the various modes of scientific inquiry, and the concept of natural rights and liberal democratic government. On the flip side, the Nazi regime was heavily influenced by late 19th Century philosophy (not all accomplishments are good?). Every discipline has an accompanying branch of philosophy that defines it's modes of inquiry and research methods, and philosophical lines of thought infiltrate every corner of the public discourse. It's just idiotic to say philosophers accomplish nothing in the real world.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>I'd also like to add that philosophy has a long history of pretty dramatic accomplishments in the real world. You can thank philosophy for science and the various modes of scientific inquiry, and the concept of natural rights and liberal democratic government. On the flip side, the Nazi regime was heavily influenced by late 19th Century philosophy (not all accomplishments are good?). If your method of answering questions yields contradictory answers to the same question (eg: "Do individual humans have moral worth? Nazism says no, liberalism says yes -- philosophy!"), then it's not very good.
- stcredzero 11y ago"His argument doesn't need a definition of conscience. He argues that if A arises from certain traits of B, then you must accept that A also arises from C, since it contains the same traits." My reading is that he's actually debunking this argument!