3 ms·
Are more civilians killed by drones or by cluster bombs[1] or "shock and awe" style campaigns? Any civilian death is a terrible thing, but if drones reduce the
by DanBC 11y ago
Are more civilians killed by drones or by cluster bombs[1] or "shock and awe" style campaigns?
Any civilian death is a terrible thing, but if drones reduce the rate of civilian death it's probably a good thing.
[1] even when we exclude cluster bombs that we the same colour as air-dropped food packages
- HappyDreamer 11y agoI would think that the logic is that if there were no drones, the US army would drop no bombs at all. I wouldn't expect them to instead start carpet bombing cities in the middle east. Reasoning in that way, the drones result in civilian deaths that wouldn't have happened without drones.
- tripzilch 11y agoIf you take away a kid's toys, they'll grow bored and start vandalizing public property in more creative ways. > I wouldn't expect them to instead start carpet bombing cities in the middle east. Except that is almost exactly what most drone-apologists are threatening the US will do instead when they argue they have to use drones because otherwise, well, they'll just have to kill more children and civilians.
- tripzilch 11y agoSo according to joering2's statistics, 4% of drone kills have been children. Maybe we can agree that's probably a bad thing. Regardless of whether killing children provides a tactical advantage (they might grow up to become terrrists, after all). However, your argument to me sounds a little like "You want us to stop using drones? Guess we'll just have to go back to murdering even more children, then. Seriously, you're forcing our hand here." And BTW, I have a brilliant idea. If you put drones over your roads that shoot missiles at drunk drivers (preferably as soon as they enter their car), it'll reduce civilian deaths! So it's probably a good thing. You only need to figure out a way to guesstimate blood-alcohol levels from a distance, but if you can get its fault tolerance below 24% (or 4% if they're drunk children), you'll have a pretty solid net-win in civilian casualties over having to transport your flying death robots halfway across the globe. import drone, random if drink() and drive() or random() < 0.24: get_blasted()