5 ms·
Arrgh! This is what annoys me about reading much philosophy. The article is about consciousness which is a term used by many different people in many ways and w
by tim333 11y ago
Arrgh! This is what annoys me about reading much philosophy. The article is about consciousness which is a term used by many different people in many ways and with many different implied definitions. But does the guy give a clear definition of what he's talking about? No he leaves it vague but waffles on for hundreds of words in a way that you can't say if it's right or wrong because you're not sure what he means.
If you are using consciousness to mean being aware of stuff in a way that you can act on it then the questions are fairly simple - humans are conscious when in a normal state, not so when knocked unconscious. Likewise rabbits. The United States can show collective consciousness in that it's citizens in aggregate can be aware of things and react. If you look at a different meaning of consciousness in terms of subjective experience then probably other people have similar experience and rabbits a simpler version but it's hard to tell.
I don't get why philosophical writing tends to be so vague and waffly. Maybe because they don't achieve much in the real world unlike say neuroscientists studying consciousness and so need to hand wave and be vague to cover up the lack of real content?
- unabst 11y agoThis sentiment is shared by many and philosophers are sympathetic. But what you are describing is a rigid logical argument which is only one way of deconstructing something. And this essay would not be as effective or may not even be possible if it were purely logical. The sense that you describe of not being able to tell if a statement is wrong is the agent and it can be thought of as mere intuition. But through the exploration of said intuitions, light is shed onto what was never shed upon before. This is the only requirement of philosophy. They are observational raw thoughts. Of course being so raw has it's disadvantages. It's vague and often unscientific. It's argumentative word play which does have a way of tripping some nerves.
- LouisSayers 11y agoUmmm... If you're going to make an argument and you aren't applying logic to that argument, then it is really not an argument worth having! Philosophy does not invite vagueness because it's philosophy - quite the opposite when I recall taking a philosophy logic class at university. Being vague is simply sloppy. If you can't write concise thoughts which clearly communicate your intention, then I for one am not going to bother reading it.
- unabst 11y agoIt is vague to those seeking logic. To those exchanging intuitions it is not vague at all. The United States is conscious is concise. The logic behind it is weak but the intuition is there, which is what matters. And from here the debate can begin as well as scientific inquiry and logical scrutiny -- all unfolding only to deepen our understanding of what is right or wrong, beautiful or ugly, real or imaginary (basically whatever your interests). Just count the comments here. A job well done.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoIntuition is no guide to truth.
- foldr 11y agoIt's a guide to truth all right, just not one that's 100% reliable.
- unfamiliar 11y agoThis is also what I find most frustrating about philosophy. Most of it seems to be like mathematics but where you don't properly outline your definitions and as a result the logic is riddled with hard to identify contradictions. Similarly, I think that proving or disproving the existence of God would be pretty trivial if anyone would willingly give a good definition of God.
- ChrisGranger 11y agoYes, in my experience, the religious are fond of saying, "You atheists can't prove God does not exist." Yet it's quite simple to prove that a particular God with a particular set of attributes [edit: does or] doesn't exist.
- 3pt14159 11y agoHow can you?
- amalcon 11y agoWhat he's getting at is probably along these lines: I define the "God" I'm looking for as an invisible green humanoid. Because something cannot be invisible and green at the same time, this "God" cannot exist. It's naturally much harder to do this with Gods that correspond to particular religions, but from time to time it is possible. E.g. a jealous God that will destroy civilization if we don't offer it human sacrifices has not done this, so it can't exist.
- drdeca 11y agoWell, what do you mean by "green"? Do you mean "which reflects or emits light of these particular wavelengths", or do you mean something about human perception? Also, similar questions apply wrt "invisible". If "green" is based on human perception, why would not an entity which, when a person looks in their direction, does not really see them like any shape, but rather, perceives some greenness in that General direction? Why would this entity not be considered both green and invisible? Alternative, does "invisible" mean to the naked human eye? What if the entity is microscopic?
- amalcon 11y agoInterestingly, the one branch of philosophy (ethics) that actually has real world applications from time to time also tends to be the most specific in terminology.
- mattmanser 11y agoObligatory pg essay link: http://www.paulgraham.com/philosophy.html http://www.paulgraham.com/philosophy.html Describes in greater detail the exact problem with philosophy you are lamenting!
- tim333 11y agoTa. I hadn't read that one.
- wodenokoto 11y agoHis argument doesn't need a definition of conscience. He argues that if A arises from certain traits of B, then you must accept that A also arises from C, since it contains the same traits. Secondly he clearly refers to a definition of conscience called phenemonology. And one must assume that "materialist" is a term in philosophy that people familiar with the field knows what entails and people not familiar with it doesn't. this paper is not an introduction to either of those terms. Your complaint is that you don't know the what these words are and that is what is apparently wrong with philosophy.
- rquantz 11y agoThank you. I'd also like to add that philosophy has a long history of pretty dramatic accomplishments in the real world. You can thank philosophy for science and the various modes of scientific inquiry, and the concept of natural rights and liberal democratic government. On the flip side, the Nazi regime was heavily influenced by late 19th Century philosophy (not all accomplishments are good?). Every discipline has an accompanying branch of philosophy that defines it's modes of inquiry and research methods, and philosophical lines of thought infiltrate every corner of the public discourse. It's just idiotic to say philosophers accomplish nothing in the real world.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>I'd also like to add that philosophy has a long history of pretty dramatic accomplishments in the real world. You can thank philosophy for science and the various modes of scientific inquiry, and the concept of natural rights and liberal democratic government. On the flip side, the Nazi regime was heavily influenced by late 19th Century philosophy (not all accomplishments are good?). If your method of answering questions yields contradictory answers to the same question (eg: "Do individual humans have moral worth? Nazism says no, liberalism says yes -- philosophy!"), then it's not very good.
- rquantz 11y agoThat is only true if the purpose of asking those questions is to find a single definitive answer.
- rwmj 11y agoWhen I started out my degree in logic & metaphysics, I came to the conclusion that philosophy needed to be much more precise. Precise philosophy already has a name: it's called physics. (In the end I transferred and finished off my degree doing mathematics and computer science.)
- mc808 11y agoI think you could argue that physics (and other sciences) are applied philosophy, but they have the same issues with imprecise definitions. Consider what it means to be a "particle" today vs. 150 years ago. Supposing the word had been rigidly defined and everyone stuck to it, "particles" as such have been debunked.
- nitrogen 11y agoThe ability of a definition to change in light of new evidence is an essential quality of a precise and useful definition. Definitions, to be useful, must be precise and falsifiable. That a definition is changed because its earlier version was falsified is evidence of precision, assuming the new definition is also falsifiable with evidence.
- ectoplasm 11y agoIt's hypotheses that are falsifiable, not definitions. Definitions simply give values to symbols.
- Pyxl101 11y agoPhysics, that is to say natural philosophy :-) E.g., Newton's "Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy" (Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica)