4 ms·
As an anarcho-capitalist, I would argue that intellectual property right violates the right of property owners. That being said, the rights of a owner of a mp3
by kiba 17y ago
As an anarcho-capitalist, I would argue that intellectual property right violates the right of property owners.
That being said, the rights of a owner of a mp3 file is overruled by a wider power enforced by the state. That owner cannot reproduce, sell, and compete at will with the originator of the mp3 file without permission. He, as owner of that particular mp3 file, cannot do with it as he see fit.
The whole system of intellectual property is government intervention into the economy for the political interests(patent lawyers, corporations that benefit from monopolies power, software developer, artists, etc). It is a system that also changes widely from nations to nations, and in history. It is an unstable system that tends toward chaos as parties compete for special privileges and political favors.
Contrast that to property right, in which anarcho-capitalist recognize it to not change over time and remain universal throughout history, regardless the whims of democracies, dictatorships, and other coercive apparatus.
How long should copyright should last, and what kind of freedom is afforded to public? Should patents last for so and so years. How should we choose non-obvious between obvious patents?
That's the question of an interventionist utilitarian technocrat who don't care much about property right but the end it achieves, not the product of a thinker who believe strongly in private property.
==Addenum==
That's the emerging views of anarcho-capitalists led by none other, a lawyer who specializes in patent.
It is also a view that have practical impact on spreading libertarian ideas by changing a think-tank organization(mises.org in this case)'s strategy toward spreading ideas and economic knowledge toward everybody else by the mere embrace of giving anything and everything information that could be given away.
We made the decision to give away everything that possibly could be given away, from code to text to the right to reprint — as far and as widely as possible. - mises.org
- grellas 17y agoThis is an interesting angle that I had never heard before. I'm not sure that I agree with the specifics but I do know that I grew up reading and enjoying Von Mises over many years for the rigor of his thinking and for his courage in standing up for unpopular views. I will look into it.
- kiba 17y agoIt would seem that you are familiar with the Austrian school, but you are not up to speed on the intellectual property controversy within libertarian circles. Well, Lugwig von Mises was a utilitarian, but not his student, Murray Rothbard.
- blasdel 17y agoMises' stance is especially notable in contrast to the insanity of Galambosianism
- kiba 17y agoLudwig von Mises does not have any opinion on the matter of Galambosianism(Global warming? Obamism? What???) since he died in 1973.
- blasdel 17y agoOh, they met alright: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Joseph_Galambos http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Joseph_Galambos
- kiba 17y agoI was not aware that Ludwig von Mises have a position on intellectual property or there is a person called Andrew Joeph Galambos. Something new to learn today I guess. Even so, I am just starting to read Austrian economic literature. So excuse my ignorance.