2 ms·
But if you see this as anthropomorphizing then you're not a materialist, or you'll have to show some qualitative, essential difference between the US and the ne
by pron 11y ago
But if you see this as anthropomorphizing then you're not a materialist, or you'll have to show some qualitative, essential difference between the US and the neurons in your brain. There is nothing to anthropomorphize because there's nothing special about the anthropos: the two are either examples of the same phenomenon or they're not.
- jerf 11y agoYou sort of ironically demonstrate the exact sort of antropomorphization I am decrying, which is the casual (as in, unexamined) assumption that the only complex state which can exist is human consciousness (or, if you prefer, "consciousness, which is the same thing that humans have"). If in fact there are other complex states that can exist, then "anthromorphization" is the act of forcing the human state onto those other possibilities. The space of complicated possibilities is much richer than the space of simple ones, and there is no a priori reason to believe that just because something is complicated, and that it has some things vaguely human-consciousness about it, that it is therefore human consciouness. Just because a 58-dimensional object contains some portion of itself that is a spherical section does not mean you have a 58-dimensional sphere. I feel justified in referring to "the" human state because in the grand possibility space of complex systems, human brains are but a point at scale, in much the same way that our little planet is just a dot. Any definition of "consciousness" that covers all possible complex systems is just another word for "complex system", and therefore useless. It isn't for me to have to prove that the quadrillion-dimensional-system of the United States is different than the billion-dimensional-system of the human consciousness [1], with wildly differing characteristics between the relationships of those dimensions... I'd say it's the other way around, that those who think it's all the same ought to give a compelling reason as to how it could possibly be the same thing, because on the fact of it it's actually even more mathematically absurd than common sense would suggest. Common sense still has that anthropomorphization built into it, deceiving you, and leading to the ideas of "pan-psychicism" where the only thing we can conceive is consciousness-as-we-know-it so the only question is how much of it something can have. [1]: My selection of the dimensionality of the human is arbitrary; my selection of the United States is obtained by simply multiplying people x human states. This is a brutal underestimate because the humans are interacting too and that creates further dimensionality, but, meh. It's really just "big numbers".