3 ms·
So we are not self aware, but our brain cells are? But aren't the brain cells themselves also just a collection of entities (molecules?)
by cortesoft 11y ago
So we are not self aware, but our brain cells are? But aren't the brain cells themselves also just a collection of entities (molecules?)
- burke 11y agoThe salient difference for me here is that the brain has a holistic factor: Individual brain cells are not self-aware, or intelligent in any capacity. A whole brain is both. Individual humans in The United States are aware of both themselves and of the United States. The United States is arguably not aware of itself in a greater-than-the-sum-of-its-parts capacity, as a human brain is. (So far I've only read the abstract of the linked article)
- 21echoes 11y agohow do you know that the United States is not aware of itself? do you think that brain cells are (would be) aware of the fact that we are conscious?
- burke 11y agoIt's a fun thought experiment, but the illusion of self probably didn't just spontaneously arise in humans; it's much more likely to be an adaptation from hundreds of thousands of generations of natural selection for a more intelligent species. Nature selected countless times, through genetic succession, for the more aware species. > do you think that brain cells are (would be) aware of the fact that we are conscious? No, a neuron is too simple a system to be capable of awareness by itself. I get what you're getting at, but if we're talking about a higher-level phenomenon, let's not also call it consciousness. In fact, we essentially use "consciousness" as a post-facto description of our own illusion of self, so it essentially makes no sense to ascribe it to a system that didn't arise more or less the same way as we did.
- sebringj 11y agoOur brain cells individually are not postulating self-awareness.