2 ms·
No. But yes. There are laws which set out exceptions to other laws. Law enforcement agencies "qualify" for these exceptions in the actioning of their duty if a
by dspillett 11y ago
No. But yes.
There are laws which set out exceptions to other laws. Law enforcement agencies "qualify" for these exceptions in the actioning of their duty if and only if they are respecting any limitations present in those exceptions and all law not explicitly updated by those exceptions.
Though I'm no lawyer, nor am I even an American, so what do I know?!
As a related-but-not-really-directly for instance: in the UK the emergency services (including the police) have exceptions allowing them to break certain driving related laws, but while doing this they must display their presence obviously, with at least the flashing lights and where necessary their sirens, so other road users are aware that a speeding vehicle may be about to enter their locality and can safely respond to that circumstance. The blues and twos are not just to get people to move out of the way, they are to inform other road users that you are there and may be speeding or performing other manoeuvres that are not normally permitted (or, at least, are generally frowned upon). Though while the exceptions allow breaking other rules in certain circumstances, there are both specific exceptions to the exceptions (there are limits to how fast the police can go in urban areas and so forth) and they are always couched in wording that means that general due diligence must be followed (the police are expected to use their judgement so even if operating within the set limits they could be reprimanded & charged if they cause damage/injury/death and it is successfully argued that no reasonable person would have taken the offending action under those circumstances.
Of course with agencies like the FBI there is a greater level of secrecy, so enforcement is more difficult. Who watches the watchers when the watchers can arrest/detain/prosecute you for watching?!