5 ms·
Wait, so my grocery store posts their add every week and as I get to the last page and I want to jump back to the front, I usually change the .../16.html to a .
by JustSomeNobody 11y ago
Wait, so my grocery store posts their add every week and as I get to the last page and I want to jump back to the front, I usually change the .../16.html to a .../1.html. I could go to prison for that?
TF!? When are lawmakers going to learn how the web works?
- ewzimm 11y agoThat's a little too extreme, but you could imagine a real example not far off. In the case where they used 13.html to list their secret cost of goods and omitted it from the button controls, skipping from 12 to 14, and you typed 13.html, then used that information to set prices for your own wholesale business, there's actually a chance you could actually get in trouble for it.
- skymt 11y agoThe relevant part of the CFAA, chopped up for readability: > Whoever ... intentionally accesses a computer without authorization or exceeds authorized access, and thereby obtains ... information from any protected computer ... shall be punished as provided in subsection (c) of this section. That requires both intent and access in excess of authorization. So since 1.html is a public page, you're authorized to read it. If 1.html was the personal information of the customer with ID #1, as in the AT&T case, that would violate CFAA. Also notable is the definition of a "protected computer." It's any computer "which is used in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce or communication," which is every computer connected to the Internet.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoSkeptic in me says this is just a nice way for AT&T to defer blame for not securing their customer's information. I've poked around websites, just to see what all is available, just by guessing URLs. I never had intention of getting anyone's personal data, of course. But, really, who hasn't done this?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dublinben 11y agoThe pages containing personal information of AT&T customers were publicly available though. We have already seen that an overzealous prosecutor will construe regular access as "without authorization or exceeds authorized access" whenever convenient.
- grkvlt 11y agoAs with everything in law, intent is key. Just because something can be accessed by the public, does not mean it is intended to be accessed by the public.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoWhat makes a page public? Opening it up so that anyone who visits a link sees it? Or actually giving the link to someone to post in public. If the latter, I have a website that one could visit but which I have never given the link out for. It seems absurd that it would be considered hacking to just visit the front page of my website whose link I have never given out but which you can guess. (0 content website of which I never actually finished designing.)
- gph 11y agoI think that's why intent is the important part of the applicable law. If I went to your website without knowing I wasn't meant to access it, then I wouldn't be breaking the law. If however you could prove in court that my intention was to access the website without your permission than I would be breaking the law. Certainly it would be very difficult to prove my intent, and there's probably nothing about your website that would make it clear I wasn't meant to access it. But if you had a bunch of private user pages that I somehow figured out how to get to even though it's apparent that I'm not meant to have access to, then I could be prosecuted for that. I think it's a terrible grey area that this law leaves open, but alas that's how it is for now.
- delecti 11y agoI would question whether the AT&T case involved "access in excess of authorization". I feel like the merest attempt to implement some access control would be necessary for that. I think he was doing enough other things that I'm not crying a river that he got punished, but IMO it sets a bad precedent.
- tzs 11y ago> I could go to prison for that? No. Analogy time! 1. Imagine a row of doors. The owner of the rooms behind the doors has given you permission to walk into any of the rooms. You enter one of the rooms. You then wish to go to the next room. You notice that there is an interior door connecting the two rooms, and so you go through that instead of going out the front door of the first room and in the front door of the second room. You are not trespassing because you have permission to be in any of the rooms. 2. Imagine another row of doors. The doors have keypad locks on them. You find out the codes for a few of the doors and notice they are sequential, and so you can guess the codes for all the doors. You do not have permission to enter any of the rooms, but since you have figured out the codes you go ahead and enter. You are trespassing, because you do not have permission to enter the rooms. It doesn't matter that the protections the owner put in place to keep you out were easy to bypass. In fact, if the owner had not locked the doors at all, you'd still be trespassing. 3. Imagine a third row of doors. They are locked. The police obtain a warrant to search one or more of the rooms. To enter the rooms they break the locks. They are not trespassing, because the warrant gives them legal permission to enter the rooms. What you are doing on your grocery store website is like #1. The case the parent comment to yours was talking about is like #2. The case the article about is like #3, although some are arguing that there are problems with the warrant that might invalidate it, which would make the case closer to #2, and would lead to exclusion of any evidence gathered under that warrant.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoCase 2 is being given a large lists of doors thousands you can go into, following the list on floors 1 and 2 noticing door, and then going to floor three and going through a door without verifying off your list. And Case 3 is like the police breaking a lock to enter a door and then insisting they didn't break the lock. They may have legal authority to break the lock, but they still broke the lock.
- dfsdfdsfxv 11y agoThis analogy is severly flawed, to the point of being essentially irrelvant. There are no locks involved here, in any way. Let's work with this row of doors analogy. The owner has invited the world to the building this hallway resides in, and has posted a list somewhere that told you about a few of the doors in this hallway. You notice there are other doors too, inbetween the doors you were told about and you enter them. That's really a far more accurate analogy. Locks require an active attempt to prevent access. Not finding the exact url as link elsewhere is extremely far from an active attempt. There's really no reason to believe the owner has any less intention for you to see it than say, the home page, which you probably accessed through a third party or by typing the url directly.