3 ms·
I actually don't think Google is in particularly great shape. They are still overly reliant on search and advertising revenues and their hold over the Android p
by threeseed 11y ago
I actually don't think Google is in particularly great shape. They are still overly reliant on search and advertising revenues and their hold over the Android platform isn't particularly strong (only via Google Play Services). They also haven't demonstrated really any skill at product management with so many failed efforts and overlap between apps/services.
It's also confusing where Google is going with some of their acquisitions e.g. Nest was expensive and arugably unnecessary and the self driving car is solid technology with very poor product positioning i.e. existing car manufacturers have their own technologies and don't want to bet their business on Apple/Google.
It seems like Google desperately wants to be a consumer company like Apple when in fact they would be much better servicing business and diversifying their revenue stream. AWS and Azure Cortana for example both should have been available from Google years ago.
- bitmapbrother 11y ago>I actually don't think Google is in particularly great shape. They are still overly reliant on search and advertising revenues I also don't think Apple is in particularly great shape. They are still overly reliant on the iPhone. What's going to happen when people stop buying iPhones? What is Apple going to do? Apple is also desperately looking for that next big thing. >their hold over the Android platform isn't particularly strong (only via Google Play Services) It's never been stronger. An Android phone released without Google Play Services and the Play Store, outside of China, is as good as dead in the water. Google is also the steward of Android contributing nearly all of source code and doing all of the R&D. Without the stewardship of Google, the gaggle of OEM clusterfucks would be releasing incompatible smartphones to lock customers into their ecosystems. >It's also confusing where Google is going with some of their acquisitions e.g. Nest was expensive and arugably unnecessary and the self driving car is solid technology with very poor product positioning i.e. existing car manufacturers have their own technologies and don't want to bet their business on Apple/Google. Nest is going to be Google's IoT company, I believe, and they're going to play an integral role in defining their vision of IoT. As for their self driving cars - the same could be said about Tesla and look what happened there. It's all about disrupting industries, not trying to make deals with the players.
- pbreit 11y agoI'm not sure anything you wrote is very accurate beyond the reliance on web search ads. Their hold on Android is very strong and is an amazing demonstration of product expertise. Nest will likely continue to make inroads into the home. Google still appears to be the self-driving car leader and it's easy to see how that could be an incredible business for it. Considering Google search and Android are (humongous) consumer products, I have no idea what you mean that it "wants to be a consumer company".
- choppaface 11y agoI'm very surprised parent-of-parent got so downvoted; I agree the point isn't very rigorous (as parent argues), but parent-of-parent isn't particularly less rigorous or more incendiary than average HN comments. There are plenty of solid reasons to doubt Google given the points that parent-of-parent draws: * Android was purchased and has plenty of product sharp edges. E.g. there are several ways to send texts. There's the issue of fragmentation. The new Google Photos has embarrassing auto-tags for African-Americans. Google has a solid whole product right now, but so did RIM. They will need to push really hard on projects like Tango and Project Fi to compete in future markets. * Nest is garnering a reputation for being untrustworthy due to absurd bugs like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BpsMkLaEiOY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BpsMkLaEiOY * Google is the most published self-driving car manufacturer, but w/out a shipping product they aren't clearly a leader. All early reviews of their car indicate that it's currently too conservative. There's also an issue: do people actually want the whole product? It looks like Tesla and Mercedes will very likely beat Google to market with core self-driving features. I agree with parent-of-parent that Google appears to be trying to position itself more aggressively in many consumer product markets. Google is an excellent technology company, but most of their products have been niche hits. There's plenty of room for their competitors to leverage better customer relationships to own good chunks of the markets that Google seeks to own.
- Oletros 11y ago> Android was purchased and has plenty of product sharp edges. E.g. there are several ways to send texts. And how is this a sharp edge? > There's the issue of fragmentation. July 2015 and still talking about fragmentation? What problem do you think is fragmentation? > The new Google Photos has embarrassing auto-tags for African-Americans. ONE case and has nothing to do with Android > Google has a solid whole product right now, but so did RIM. And this can be said about Apple or Microsoft