4 ms·
They write melodramatic postmortems on Medium which fail to identify why exactly their startup failed. Afterward, they either a) do another startup or b) join
by minimaxir 11y ago
They write melodramatic postmortems on Medium which fail to identify why exactly their startup failed.
Afterward, they either a) do another startup or b) join an established company, depending on how jaded they are from the experience.
- lobe 11y agoThat first part isn't fair to the startup founders. I know a couple of founders of failed startups who wrote post-mortems on Medium, and then when it surfaced on HN the comments were stating that the founders were glossing over the important issues. In both circumstances the post-mortems outlined clearly why the company failed, it was just that readers saw a side to the story which the founder didn't expand upon (either as they didn't feel it was important, or out of respect to those they worked with) and assumed there were secrets hidden there that explain the failure. I knew the full story of these startups, it was as told in the postmortem (one of which explicitly stated "we failed because of X"). Judging by some of the comments I read, some people don't want to believe the truth that's told to them. They assume they know more about the situation than the founder that lived it.
- tlb 11y agoIt's often hard to know why a startup failed. For example, if you released something but got few sales, it's hard to know if the product wasn't executed well enough, or your sales & marketing were weak, or there's simply no market. Would a couple more iterations have brought success? You can never be sure.
- minimaxir 11y agoThat's the exact reason why I'm not a fan of them. Most of the posts on Medium are made less forewarning and more a last ditch publicity event.
- radicality 11y agoThe top of the silicon valley hierarchy of needs (https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CHnRlpfUEAA9b6R.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CHnRlpfUEAA9b6R.jpg)
- sharmi 11y agoI think it is not healthy to be critical of postmortems written by founders, in general. * It is usually hard to talk about failures and especially if one has contributed to the failure significantly. * It gives a counter perspective to the rosy pictures painted about startups by the media and tries to right the balance of views presented to the aspiring entrepreneurs. It helps to provide a reality check of what can really be expected and if startup is really the reader's cup of tea. * On a personal level, it is an attempt by the founder to lay it all out and move on. So obviously there is some melodrama in it. Considering that, there are so many people in tech who suffer from depression and never talk about it, and we really have to coax some to take help, now that someone really tries to share their turmoil with the broader community, we should rather be welcoming than critical. After all, no one is going to fail their startup, just to write a melodramatic post on Medium. ;)