4 ms·
Pao had thousands of people calling her a ching-chong cunt. Why do you think your comment is relevant to this thread?
by DanBC 11y ago
Pao had thousands of people calling her a ching-chong cunt. Why do you think your comment is relevant to this thread?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lcswi 11y agoThousands of people? Where did you get that number from? Also, there were (misguided) reasons for people to be upset, which does not justify the racism, but hey, extreme insults are normal if you are very angry (no, not just on the Internet but also outside tech filter bubbles).
- ewzimm 11y agoNobody is debating that extreme insults are normal when people get angry. What people are saying is that it needs to stop being normal.
- lcswi 11y agoI totally support that, but the Internet is probably the worst and hardest place to try initiate that change. Opposed to the real world, wannabe bullies have zero chance of seeing a reaction from their victims if those do not react. Online bullies like there DO lose their interest. Just look at past outrages on reddit to see. People need to despise that these short-term hype shitstorms are not worth reacting to'. Maybe ask PR campaigners how they handle it, there should be decades of research. I am obviously excluding actual stalkers, sociopaths etc. Those are hard problems but not one you can as easily treat and not a widespread problem.
- ewzimm 11y agoI definitely think the solution has to be deeper than banning people from forums. People exhibiting sociopathic tendencies have needs that aren't being met in their real lives. They most likely need therapy, counseling, or community support. They might have abusive home lives. The online harrassment issue is a big warning sign that there are deep social issues all over the world that aren't being addressed, but everyone knew that already. What this really calls for is expanded mental health care, but I don't know if anyone is going to respond that way, since it's expensive and requires a lot of people doing hard work.
- lcswi 11y agoThat is a post worth bookmarking/screenshotting for future reference. Thank you, well said!
- Nadya 11y agoI'd much rather eradicate murder. Murder sucks. It needs to stop being a normal day-to-day occurrence in our lives. Someone, somewhere will be murdered today. How can you continue with your life knowing that will happen? Worse - it will be more than one person! Multiple people will be murdered today, tomorrow, and every day in the future too! Most of them are total strangers, but maybe one day it will be someone you know. I don't want to live in a world like that. In fact, I don't think anyone wants to live in a world with murder. We have laws against it, we punish murderers, but murder still happens! All of our attempts over thousands of years have failed to eradicate murder! There has to be more we can do! Do you have suggestions? ------ In case my point isn't made clear: there are some things that are simply facts of life. You will not be able to solve them. People are emotional and will react on those emotions. Sometimes people will do terrible things while acting on these emotions. Sometimes we will fight with one another, sometimes we will throw fists at one another, sometimes we will call each other names. We'll bury each other 6' under ground. These are things that happen. We know they happen. We expect them to happen. While none of us wishes these things happen, we recognize that they will happen. That recognition of things that will happen is what makes those things normal. Normal things do not get our attention. We haven't been trained to care about expected, normal things. I recognize that tomorrow morning, the sun will rise. It's a very special event. It means the sun is still burning and providing light and life to the planet. It's a normal occurrence though. The sun will rise the day after tomorrow. In fact, the sun will likely rise every day for the rest of my life. It's an expected occurrence. It's a normal one. I don't celebrate it. I don't pay attention to it, most of the time. Some days I might appreciate the sunrise and the beauty of it. Most days it gets ignored. Some days I notice some terrible occurrence happening in the world. Those terrible things happen every day. They're normal. So most days. They get ignored.
- fixermark 11y agoWith respect (because I share the feeling), that's an attitude that helps one sleep at night in a broken world, but it's inherently defeatist and decreases the likelihood of positive change. Because things can be changed. Over the work of several decades, the murder rate (along with the violent crime rate) has gone down. Why should we just assume that the same can't be said for bullying and abuse? There's plenty of question of how much we're willing to spend to solve the problem, of course (to give a terrible ad absurdium example, it's trivial to stop Internet bullying by shutting off the internet). But when we just hand-wave and say "Can't be fixed," we aren't helping.
- skarper 11y agoThe article speaks wider than Pao's own personal experience and speaks on the internet as a whole
- VikingCoder 11y agoPao had thousands of accounts calling her a ching-chong cunt. There's potentially a big difference. I'm not defending the slur - it's abhorrent. But if the magnitude matters to you, let's try to be accurate when we describe what we're counting.
- paulhauggis 11y agoReally? So you are going to count the number of "accounts" now? She was bullied and forced to resign. This is the standard operating procedure of many here on HN and on the Internet (Mozilla CEO anyone?): Someone just can't have a differing opinion. They need to be bullied, tormented, silenced, fired, and marginalized until they admit that their opinion is wrong. It was all based on mis-information (many still don't know why the AmA employee was fired) and mob mentality. Just remember this conversation when you get fired because someone does research on your your Internet comments and decides that one of your opinions is deemed "offensive". It will most likely happen someday. I also find it a little funny that when someone in a git repository doesn't use specific gender pronouns, they are called out as biased (and bullied). But when hundreds and thousands of people call a woman racial slurs (so much worse), it's defended. This is my point exactly: Most people talking about 'equality' are lying. They want equality when someone is against their own personal beliefs, but are just fine spewing the same hate and bigotry when the roles are reversed.
- danielweber 11y agoThis modern trend of trying to fire people whose speech we don't like is nuts. I suspect, possibly incorrectly, that it's being done heavily by people who have never tried to support a family and don't realize the extreme damage their "hobby" has on the world.
- VikingCoder 11y agoI don't think it's modern - every elected politician has faced this.
- facepalm 11y agoReal trolls exist, but other than that, I must admit I was also thinking that a rallying cry against trolling is usually just a cry to shut down people somebody disagrees with. Actual trolling without content is usually well covered by user agreements and general law.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- josefresco 11y ago"Pao had thousands of people calling her a ching-chong cunt." Is this a known/established fact? I see in the article a paragraph about how she received thousands of positive notes/emails but nothing about the # or volume of hate. It may not be documented here, but I'm curious if it was actually as widespread as implied.
- DanBC 11y agoMaybe it was only hundreds of people using ten accounts each, but you only have to look at her comment history to see all the messages.
- fixermark 11y agoHundreds of people on ten accounts each having the capacity to look like thousands of people is part of the problem Ellen Pao's essay is trying to highlight. We're still human beings, and even though we all abstractly know that throwaway accounts exist, when you're getting 10,000 PMs that say you suck, it matters. Besides, evidence from Twitter suggests that it's demonstrably more often an easily-led mob than hundreds of sock-puppets these days.
- kyoji 11y agoThe front page of Reddit was littered with derogatory Pao posts for days on end following the shutdown of /r/fph and firing of Victoria. I'm sure she also received a large amount of private hate messages too.
- josefresco 11y agoI saw the front page, and many (most?) were not of the "ching-chong cunt" variety. I witnessed a lot of misplaced hate (we now know is "misplaced" after the fact) but there's a difference between "flaming" someone and using racist/bigoted language.
- lfuller 11y agoI've read through many of the top threads on Pao over the past few weeks, and from my experience about 30% of all posts publicly used the word "cunt" to describe Pao.
- Demiurge 11y agoWhat does it have to do with trolls, or internet, for that matter?
- istvan__ 11y agoLike other people display Obama as a non-american, Donald Trump as Hitler and so on. As a public character you should be able to handle that.
- Nadya 11y agoHow many thousands of people weren't? Was it statistically significant? Or is this another case of focusing on the insignificant <1%, many of which are trolls, and pretending it's somehow a majority or significant amount of people with sincere feelings[0]? [0] http://i.imgur.com/lTMU3Vy.png http://i.imgur.com/lTMU3Vy.png
- curiousjorge 11y agoWhat makes you think that kind of vulgar racial slur (even if it's a reference) is excusable? By referencing it you've added to that voice.
- lfuller 11y agoThat doesn't seem to follow to me. If you ignore or suppress abusive language that doesn't make it stop - it just means you've accepted it.
- DanBC 11y agoParent comment says that people call mild, polite, disagreement trolling. This thread is about Pao calling out trolls. It's pretty fucking important to make people realise that this is not polite disagreement about some obscure topic, but that it is very many people leaving posts that are little more than "Pao is a cunt" or using racial slurs. It's weird that you object to the racial slur but ignore the sexual slur.
- kzhahou 11y agoHundreds of thousands strongly disagreement with firing Victoria, and the overall deterioration of the admin relationship. But let's focus on the brats instead.
- DanBC 11y agoIn a thread that's talking about the "brats", yeah, let's focus on them. There were plenty of other threads for you to talk about the firing (not Pao) and failing admin relationship (not Pao) or censorship (not Pao).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kzhahou 11y agoI never actually saw a post saying "ching-chong cunt". Can you point to one? I searched for [ching chong cunt reddit] and didn't find anything either. I did see lots of posts saying things like "Ellen Pao is LITERALLY Hitler", but not any overtly racist ones that I can recall.
- DanBC 11y ago(Edit: removed rudeness.) Here's one. There were lots of others that used the term cunt or used racial slurs. https://np.reddit.com/r/punchablefaces/comments/39dl6s/ching_chong_ding_wong/cs2l6gv https://np.reddit.com/r/punchablefaces/comments/39dl6s/ching... I mean, it's a comment on a thread in a sub called "punchable faces", the thread links to an Imgur image of Pao labled "ching chong ding dong", has 2,400 upvotes.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoPeople, in a moment of anger, will AGREE with something hurtful that was said? Shocking! I would say we should not confuse an upvote with a post.
- xyzzyz 11y agoCan you point one which wasn't downvoted to oblivion? This one is pretty bad example to give, when you're trying to convince people that "thousands" were of this opinion. I really recommend reading comments in that thread.