3 ms·
Because nobody is building any of the components for Mars Direct. However many of the components for these missions either exist already or are currently in act
by simonh 11y ago
Because nobody is building any of the components for Mars Direct. However many of the components for these missions either exist already or are currently in active development. To do Mars Direct now you'd have to factor in the cost of scrapping everything that's currently in the works and developing Mars Direct from scratch.
I appreciate your POV, Mars Direct is a compelling plan, but it's weakness is that none of its components except the launcher are any use for anything else except another Mars Direct mission. Anyway it's a bit unfair to thrash these guys for wanting to work within what is already actually happening.
- nkoren 11y agoIn other words, they're stuck in the Sunk Costs fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunk_costs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunk_costs
- simonh 11y agoI don't think you properly understand what the falacy is. The falacy is to factor in a sunk cost that has no future value in future decisions. For this proposal to be subject to that falacy, you'd have to show that the products of the current development programs have no future value.
- nkoren 11y agoI'm afraid I have to turn around and say that it is you who does not have a proper understanding of the sunk costs fallacy. The future value of the sunk costs is not important -- in fact, thinking that it is important is the very definition of the fallacy. Rather, the future value of all costs is what is important, whether those costs are sunk or not. To illustrate, here's a simplified example. We can buy one of two Mars missions: Mars Mission A, which costs $100, of which we have already paid a $10 non-refundable deposit, and Mars Mission B, which costs $30, but we have not yet spent anything on it. The $10 we have already spent absolutely does have future value -- $10 worth of future value, if we pursue Mars Mission A. Its future value is, however, irrelevant, because Mars Mission A has $90 worth of future costs, compared to $30 of future costs for Mars Mission B. The Sunk Costs Fallacy is to believe that the $10 continues to have any relevance in such a scenario. In truth, the future costs are the only costs which matter.