3 ms·
It seems like there are two separate kinds of cruft: stuff that is distracting and gets in the way (social buttons, privacy policy modal, big nav-bar with tempe
by sanderjd 11y ago
It seems like there are two separate kinds of cruft: stuff that is distracting and gets in the way (social buttons, privacy policy modal, big nav-bar with temperature, ads, etc.), and stuff that happens in the background and doesn't get in the way, but makes things slow (multiple ad network embeds, optimizely, analytics scripts, etc.). While I agree that the first category has a lot to do with organization structure and incentives, the second category seems like it may be a good business opportunity for a new generation of "low-cruft" solutions to the same problems. For instance, I was kind of astounded that optimizely only has a crufty javascript solution, rather than a (probably far more complex) less crufty pure server-side solution, and I spent awhile looking around for such a thing, but found nothing much. Or something that puts all the tracking and analytics that different departments want to do behind a single optimized script (maybe segment.io already does this?).
tl;dr; The problem that lots of different people that contribute to a website are vying for the user's attention in different ways doesn't seem to have a technical solution, but the problem that we're making too many third-party requests that respond with too much data and/or run too much javascript seems like one that could be solved if tools focused on it.
- Touche 11y agoI would say the biggest problem with pages like this is that it "jumps" around as content is loaded. The fact that ads are lazy loaded is not bad (probably good actually!). This is easily fixed by simply having the container set to exact width/height so that it doesn't mess with the rest of the page when it loads. CNN also has a sidebar that pops in with other stories. Don't do that. Render it on the server. Just a couple of fixes like this and the page would be fine, even if some extra stuff takes a while to load. They key from the user perspective is that the article should immediately be readable when the page loads.
- pcwalton 11y agoThe fact that ads are lazy-loaded can be a big performance problem if it's implemented with a method that causes browsers to turn off async pan/zoom. Especially sad is when images are loaded this way, because most browsers will load images on scroll automatically, so this technique of "lazy loading" ads for "performance" actually cripples scrolling performance with no benefit.
- Touche 11y ago> if it's implemented with a method that causes browsers to turn off async pan/zoom. What technique would cause that?
- baudehlo 11y agoSegment(io) doesn't have a solution for this, in case you decide to go searching. And their server side APIs have plenty of issues of their own (eg no way to get utm parameters to the destination - hugely frustrating and we are still working with them on that).
- sanderjd 11y agoThanks for the info. When I first heard about their product, I got excited that they were trying to solve this issue, but after reading their marketing materials and documentation decided that it didn't work how I expected, but I wasn't sure.