4 ms·
> Non-atomic objects are not illusions: http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896 http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896 Quite right! It's the folk-theories of those objec
by eli_gottlieb 11y ago
> Non-atomic objects are not illusions: http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896 http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896
Quite right! It's the folk-theories of those objects that are illusions, in the sense of providing intuitive but false causal explanations for the phenomena in question.
>The word "illusion" ought to be all but struck from philosophy, in my opinion. It seems to lead philosophers down a road of reductionism until they explode into a paroxysm of reductionism so complete that they won't even admit subatomic particles "exist".
The word should be doubly struck-out because the same philosophers, in the attempt to get out of that paroxysm, tend to start reifying more and more concepts into metaphysical "existence", until they wind up claiming that reductionism just doesn't really work and we were bloody idiots to try it in the first place. Reversing idiocy doesn't get you accuracy.
>It remains a current theory that time is not an atomic element of our universe, and that it may arise from something else (entropy? the connections in loop quantum gravity? something something holographic principle?), but regardless of what the truth is, "time" as a useful concept won't go anywhere.
Since "time" as we talk about it really means causal ordering, I can't see how any of those other things can replace time. It's not exactly a radical statement to say, in a post-relativity physics, that time isn't a real scalar but instead a more complex causal ordering that happens to look like a real scalar when you work at Newtonian scales.