5 ms·
If time is an illusion, what explains the illusion? What's the illusion made of? How can I get more of it, or lose it? Sure, there are time-dilation effects
by eli_gottlieb 11y ago
If time is an illusion, what explains the illusion? What's the illusion made of? How can I get more of it, or lose it?
Sure, there are time-dilation effects in special and general relativity, but those are theories that explicitly mention time and timelike dimensions. Time, in those theories, is not at all an illusion.
So: if it's an illusion, what is the illusion made of?
- howeyc 11y agoI wouldn't call it an illusion. Perception of motion maybe? More like humans agreed that X oscillations of element Y counts as 1 second. We all agree on the length of 1 second on earth and go from there. We use that time unit as a reference to explain the motion we perceive.
- ommunist 11y agoright you are. Clocks measure distance, that by common agreement we call 'time'. It is practically useful only because we have memory.
- peteretep 11y ago> if it's an illusion, what is the illusion made of Would the inability of prehistoric desert tribes to explain mirages or the movement of the stars have made those things less real?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- CuriousSkeptic 11y agoOne explanation I picked up in a book some time ago was that the illusion could be explained as a series of moments (like the frames of a movie), due to the fact that each such moment contained an encoding of the previous frame (your memory) and an anticipation of future frames (your expectations) the illusion that the individual moments are connected in a linear progression emerges, much like the illusion of motion emerges from watching movie frames.
- CuriousSkeptic 11y agoJust brain dumping here but I have this thought that maybe the universe unfolds like a grammar. You start with a description of everything that can exist according to some laws of physics, if you do this recursively, like a grammar. You would have a root node (this would be the Big Bang) from there you generate every possible state. This would result in a tree where each node (present) is either the Big Bang or hangs of some other tree (the past) and has branches for each possible configuration (futures) to generate from that state.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThat's still a causally structured universe, which does thus actually have a kind of time (the causal arrow of time) built into it.
- ommunist 11y agoit is made from neural correllates of consciousness. Your brain basically runs this gfx. its complicated, but can be understood. I pointed earlier to Metzinger's popular narration about that.
- danbruc 11y agoUnless you are convinced that time or even the entire universe will end when the last human (or animal or alien) dies, this is nonsense.
- ommunist 11y agoyou do not know that, there is no method to prove. For practical purposes we can have 'time'. But it does not mean it exists. Look, it is uneasy concept, I know. But it is not Kantian at all. The thing is that we build tools to augment our limited senses, but we cannot build tools to augment depth of our understanding. If the language has no word for phenomena, it cant be explained or exposed. But its reality is undeniable. Ever had something you know but you cant explain? It does not mean the thing you know does not exist, right? Such is the uneasy truth that there is no 'time' or 'self'.
- danbruc 11y agoThere is solipsism, the idea that nothing but your mind exists. And it is a valid idea because you can not be sure that anything exists. The entire universe, everything you think you see, hear, smell or feel might just be an illusion created by your mind. The idea that things change with time or that time exists, that you can move your body through space or that space exists or you have a body to begin with, all this may just be an illusion of your mind. But while this is an interesting idea to ponder about it is also not very helpful. If true you are lost and there is nothing you can ever learn about the world. Maybe you can explore the illusion created by your mind but even this only if your mind behaves nicely and does not randomly decide to completely change the illusion or whatnot. It seems to make a lot more sense to assume not everything is just an illusion, believe that there is a real world accessible by your senses and then explore this world. And once you have decided that there is a real world it no longer makes sense to ascribe a special role to you or your mind because that is part of the position you just left behind. it is made from neural correllates of consciousness. Your brain basically runs this gfx. This is also inconsequential - you say that time is an illusion created by your brain but that still requires that your brain exists in some reality and that it is doing things which prerequisite time because doing means change over time. It might of course be the case that there is a time in the real world that allows things to happen and your mind might create an internal representation of that, the thing we call time, that is a poor representation of the true nature of time, but that does not mean time does not exist, it means there is the real thing and the thing we perceive. And this may actually be the likely scenario because there are hints in physics that neither time nor space are fundamental things but are the result of something more fundamental in a similar way that atoms are made out of quarks and electrons.
- golergka 11y agoYou are an illusion, basically. You, the observer who goes through time from past to the future at some rate, is just an abstraction that evolved in a process of evolution because created with higher cognitive abilities were better at survival, and at some point their cognitive abilities developed a very useful illusion of "self".
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThere are still causal arrows between the different moments of conscious cognition, and it's the causal arrows that are Time on a reality-level, not the awareness thereof.
- jerf 11y agoNon-atomic objects are not illusions: http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896 http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896 The word "illusion" ought to be all but struck from philosophy, in my opinion. It seems to lead philosophers down a road of reductionism until they explode into a paroxysm of reductionism so complete that they won't even admit subatomic particles "exist". Further the idea that either A: I can explain it or B: it doesn't "exist" really ought to be struck too... even in 1908 I would have called that sheer ivory tower arrogance but in light of what we know today is it simply absurd. There are true, meaningful, and incomprehensibly large statements, such as "a true specification of the full state of the world economy". (In theory nothing prevents such a statement from being produced, but you won't be fitting that into your head anytime soon.) There is always C: I can't explain it but it exists. It remains a current theory that time is not an atomic element of our universe, and that it may arise from something else (entropy? the connections in loop quantum gravity? something something holographic principle?), but regardless of what the truth is, "time" as a useful concept won't go anywhere.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago> Non-atomic objects are not illusions: http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896 http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2896 Quite right! It's the folk-theories of those objects that are illusions, in the sense of providing intuitive but false causal explanations for the phenomena in question. >The word "illusion" ought to be all but struck from philosophy, in my opinion. It seems to lead philosophers down a road of reductionism until they explode into a paroxysm of reductionism so complete that they won't even admit subatomic particles "exist". The word should be doubly struck-out because the same philosophers, in the attempt to get out of that paroxysm, tend to start reifying more and more concepts into metaphysical "existence", until they wind up claiming that reductionism just doesn't really work and we were bloody idiots to try it in the first place. Reversing idiocy doesn't get you accuracy. >It remains a current theory that time is not an atomic element of our universe, and that it may arise from something else (entropy? the connections in loop quantum gravity? something something holographic principle?), but regardless of what the truth is, "time" as a useful concept won't go anywhere. Since "time" as we talk about it really means causal ordering, I can't see how any of those other things can replace time. It's not exactly a radical statement to say, in a post-relativity physics, that time isn't a real scalar but instead a more complex causal ordering that happens to look like a real scalar when you work at Newtonian scales.