11 ms·
The crazy thing about all the Mars missions I have read about is they optimising for the cheapest component - the humans. Until we have a problems finding volun
by danieltillett 11y ago
The crazy thing about all the Mars missions I have read about is they optimising for the cheapest component - the humans. Until we have a problems finding volunteers then this is very suboptimal.
- onion2k 11y agoThere might be a long queue of people willing to volunteer but 99.9999% of them would be incapable of doing the job so the mission would fail. Most would give up before they leave Earth. A lot would break down and make errors during the travel. Of the remaining few, most wouldn't be able to do useful science at the other end. If you want the mission to be more successful than "Yay, we got a human corpse to crash on Mars!" then you need to optimise for attracting people who can actually successfully execute the mission operations. That isn't so cheap.
- danieltillett 11y agoSure 99.9% of all humans might not make the grade, but out of 7 billion people I think we can find more than a handful who would. In the end it does not matter as you optimise to the level you need to attract the candidates required to do the job. Anything else is just over engineering. Edit. I don't think we would have a major problem attracting Apollo-level candidates even if the chance of success was less than 50%.
- pstuart 11y agoOr once we have real AI it could run the mission and the humans would be more like passengers who could spend most of the trip in some kind of suspended animation.
- danieltillett 11y agoYou don’t even need real AI to do this. Years ago I worked out a way to get humans to mars for under 1 billion per person by using off the shelf components and existing infrastructure by not optimising for humans. I should write it up as it is at least entertaining (most people I told were equal part horrified/impressed).
- pstuart 11y agoPlease share your write up if you get a chance. I was being a bit playful with 2001: A Space Odyssey