5 ms·
The Truth About Tamiflu: Has the US wasted $1.5 billion on an ineffective drug?
- patrickgzill 17y agoShocking ... and yet not so shocking, when you consider the other marketing activities pharma companies get into. Viagra is probably the best example for heavy marketing of a drug (at least in the US): TV ads, NASCAR sponsorship, etc.
- tdoggette 17y agoYes, but Pfizer isn't engaging in large-scale deception that costs billions of dollars and risks millions of lives when they show a car smashing through a billboard that says "Erectile Dysfunction" on it.
- electromagnetic 17y agoViagra is probably the most heavily marketed drugs in Canada, beside the fact they cannot legally say you need it or even describe what it fixes unless it's in information handed out to your doctor. It doesn't stop it being in prime time adverts that make zero sense and being plastered around sporting events. Honestly, I don't remember cigarettes being marketed so heavily to the public, which disturbs me greatly about what the pharma companies are intending with viagra and other identical drugs.
- Alex3917 17y agoAnd once again I ask, how are you supposed to make an informed decision about health issues when there's a good chance the CDC is lying about the data: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=894903 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=894903
- tokenadult 17y agoThe only lies about autism and vaccines are coming from the people who fear vaccines. Autism is definitely not something for which risk increases if people are vaccinated. That is about as replicated a finding as medical science has. http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=2962 http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=2962
- Alex3917 17y agoWho said anything about autism?
- tokenadult 17y agoThe link http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=894903 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=894903 you submitted earlier and just linked back to above.
- Alex3917 17y agoRight, I don't believe nor have I ever believed that vaccines cause autism. What I do believe is that the systemic design of the CDC makes it impossible to trust what they say for various reasons.
- scott_s 17y agoWhile gesturing at an article that claims childhood vaccines cause autism. I have difficulty accepting someone's analysis of a federal organization when they also clearly do not understand how science works.
- GiraffeNecktie 17y agoA more nuanced view is available on the Effect Measure blog (http://scienceblogs.com/effectmeasure/2009/12/the_tamiflu_doesnt_work_non-st.php#c2138915 http://scienceblogs.com/effectmeasure/2009/12/the_tamiflu_do...).
- gojomo 17y agoThat's a useful perspective, but I often get the sense from 'revere' (at Effect Measure) that he's shading his analysis to promote "the message" he thinks the public needs to hear. For example, in the link you provided he impugns the motives of the publishers of this latest analysis, and says about the their acceptance of the paper: "I don't think it served the public purpose or the public health." A couple places, he emphasizes "during a pandemic, no less" or "here we are in the middle of a pandemic" as factors that should weigh against raising doubts about Tamiflu's effectiveness at this time. That kind of political calculation applied to scientific or medical results creeps me out -- and often backfires on the officials who try it.
- GiraffeNecktie 17y agoHis blog is completely focused on public health so it seems reasonable that he frames his response in those terms (i.e. what serves the public purpose and public health). He made several points about the study: that it didn't say anything that wasn't known (i.e. Tamiflu is of limited value); their methodology was murky; and the way it was handled by the BMJ contributed to sensationalizing the story in a way that might make Tamiflu not used in situations where it would have some value. Seems like a valid point to say that there's an impact on public health.
- duncanj 17y agoYet, it is a pandemic. That fact does change the calculus of whether to recommend treatment. Do you say, "I don't have enough evidence yet to recommend it?" Or do you say, "Based on the evidence we have, it is a good idea?" There is no right answer until post-pandemic studies.
- 17y ago
- JunkDNA 17y agoWhen I read this article to my wife (a physician) she was not the least bit surprised. She asked me why it was even news. She has spent the last several months trying to convince patients that Tamiflu isn't indicated for people who are otherwise healthy because the benefit vs. risk is not really favorable. Many become very irate when presented with this information and demand the medicine anyway, on the grounds that "other doctors" are giving it out to everyone.
- pragmatic 17y agoSo did she prescribe the drug anyway? Doctors are pressured by patients to prescribe pain killers, anit-biotics, etc. But isn't it up to the doctor to say yes or no?
- anamax 17y agoIf it does no harm and the patient is paying for it, why not say yes? Note the "if the patient is paying" clause. MDs shouldn't be doing cost-benefit tradeoffs - patients should. Politicians shouldn't be doing cost-benefit tradeoffs either. (That's a statement against interest - my demographic group has way more say than other groups, so we'll be subsidized by politicians. And no, it won't be different this time.)
- stavrianos 17y agoYou're thinking of a pharmacist. MDs and politicians should absolutely be doing cost-benefit tradeoffs. I'd go so far as to say that's basically their job. I go to a doctor because they have skills and knowledge I don't possess. That doctors (being experts) so often don't apply their judgment, and politicians (often being charismatic amateurs) so often do is lamentable. Politicians should be required to be experts. Doctors should be (aren't they?) required to exhibit judgment on behalf of their patients. Expecting everyone to be able to exhibit the judgment of a professional in every field is so wildly implausible that I've obviously mistaken your meaning.
- 17y ago
- drhowarddrfine 17y agoI've known this for a year or so and thought everyone else did, too. Only recently did I see stories about this again and was quite surprised.
- aaronsw 17y agoThis is pretty much par for the course for new drugs and goes a long way toward explaining why we're such an overmedicalized society: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/17244 http://www.nybooks.com/articles/17244
- pragmatic 17y agoAgain, the DOCTOR prescribe the medicine not the patient. Why would the doctor prescribe unneeded/unnecessary medicine? I understand the social pressure etc. However, when I go to a doctor I expect him/her to prescribe something that is necessary not just write a script to get me out of the office. Can much of health care problems be pinned directly on the doctors? I know its unpopular to criticize doctors, but I'm beginning to think that we can only address the health issue by directly confronting the MD's.
- fnid 17y agoAlso consider that doctors get kickbacks from the pharmas for prescribing certain medicines, in addition to lots of perks like swag, vacations, etc piled on them by marketing reps.
- dangoldin 17y agoThe doctor writes the prescription because if he/she doesn't you go to another doctor who will. They don't want to lose your business and are willing to write a prescription to make you happy. If all the doctors agreed to not write unnecessary prescriptions you wouldn't have this problem but that's unlikely to happen since only a few doctors will deviate to get the extra patients.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoA 2006 Cochrane review of Tamiflu came to similar conclusions -- based largely on a paper that looked at ten studies, all of them funded by the company [Roche]. This kind of reporting annoys me. It's a logical fallacy that having a stake in the outcome makes your research invalid. And who else is going to fund a study? Nobody without a stake is going to foot the bill. If the drug is going to be used to prevent death, it seems reasonable to ask whether or not its potentially deadly side effects are outweighed Quite the opposite. If the patient is likely to die anyway, then side effects be damned. It's time for a "Hail Mary" play. Get the patients past the immediate danger, and sort the rest out later. The answer may lie in the politics of disease. Sorry to be political here, but this is exactly what you'll be getting more of when the government starts to dictate how much will be spent on what kind of healthcare. When lobbyists or constituents are pushing for something to be covered, even though they're ignorant or are just interested in profits, the politicians will tilt the rules toward the squeaky wheel rather than rational science.
- Hoff 17y agoAs-yet unseen endings of the "someone is wrong on the Internet" http://xkcd.com/386/ http://xkcd.com/386/ ... - commercial interests. - advertising. - religious beliefs. - political party affiliations. - market transparency. - peer pressure - etc. That there are marginal drugs has long been an issue; how many of us read the available studies? In some cases, you'll find a commercially-successful drug is little better than placebo, or little better than a generic. The most reliable approach toward truth and knowledge in a capitalism-based society? Follow the revenues. Find and then follow what the folks involved value. Often monetary profit or status within the group.
- ssn 17y agoFYI: Tamiflu is not related to the H1N1 vaccines.
- dubcomesaveme 17y agohttp://www.wired.com/medtech/drugs/magazine/17-09/ff_placebo_effect http://www.wired.com/medtech/drugs/magazine/17-09/ff_placebo...
- jacoblyles 17y agoHypothesis: Democratic governments make bad decisions in the face of popular panic. Hypothesis 2: Interested actors often try to stoke popular panic to get governments to make rash decisions that benefit themselves.