3 ms·
You say that gold has value. What is that value? Certainly there's some value in using it for things like electronic contacts, but that doesn't come anywhere cl
by mikeash 11y ago
You say that gold has value. What is that value? Certainly there's some value in using it for things like electronic contacts, but that doesn't come anywhere close to accounting for the price. If you buy an ounce of gold right now, the $1323 is maybe $13 practical utility and $1310 collective faith in its use as a currency. Do you think that tiny bit of utility is enough, or do you disagree with my assessment that gold mostly has no value?
- Ologn 11y agoHistory is often clearer than the present, so let's look at the price of silver around 1980. In 1979 silver was $6 an ounce, by 1980 it was worth $48.70 an ounce by 1982 it was back below $5. Was silver really have $48 of value in 1982 dollars? Clearly not. Over the short term the price of gold, silver, subprime real estate, dutch tulip bulbs, pets.com stock etc. can soar over its real value. Over the longer term, price and value always come back together though. > the $1323 is maybe $13 practical utility and $1310 collective faith in its use as a currency But non-speculators pay $1323 to fill teeth and conduct electricity. For them, the $1323 is 100% for practical utility. Of course, as the value of gold soars, they look for alternative products to fill these needs (ceramic, copper). Over the long term, I think gold derives 0% of its price from anything other than its value, over the short term, different factors come into play (like silver in 1980).
- mikeash 11y agoThe vast majority of gold ever mined sits around doing nothing. If it was seriously useful for practical purposes then people would pay a lot more than $1323/ounce for things like plating electrical conductors, in order to get that gold out of vaults and people's dresser drawers and into useful applications. Compare with oil, which stores pretty well, but where the vast majority of oil that is extracted is used rather than stored.
- ori_b 11y ago> But non-speculators pay $1323 to fill teeth and conduct electricity. Well, It tends not to be used for fillings any more, and for coating conductors, only a tiny amount is used. Even then, half the time the gold plating is social value ("Audio connector with GOLD PLATED TIPS!", rather than practical value. Mostly, it just sits in stockpiles, though; it's practical value is less than the value of stockpiling it. > I think gold derives 0% of its price from anything other than its value This is a tautology. However, a large portion of that value comes from the perception of value. It's valuable because people think it's valuable.
- nhaehnle 11y agoDon't forget the use of gold for jewelry, which dwarfs the other uses.
- mikeash 11y agoYes, but it's not really useful as jewelry, just admired. People can admire large numbers with interesting cryptographic properties too, so I don't think this is something you can use to separate Bitcoin from gold.