5 ms·
> Do people actually sign up for newsletters from these things? Yes. This is a very successful way to increase those numbers > Does this actually work? A mor
by kristopolous 11y ago
> Do people actually sign up for newsletters from these things?
Yes. This is a very successful way to increase those numbers
> Does this actually work?
A more important question! The issue is that the numbers that the website owner is trying to get up are really low to begin with - usually <1% or so.
So you have to think like a Bayesian here. What are the chances of someone who isn't computer literate enough to know there's a way to dismiss the dialog and believes that giving their email address is the only way to continue?
Even if 99.8% of users are smart enough to x out of that dialog, then bam, you've increased your newsletter membership by 20%!!! (simply by confusing 0.2% of your visitors) Congratulations! Look at how effective you are! You're now giving a bunch of novice computer users email they don't want and shit they won't read!
- emodendroket 11y agoThey also drive up donations and I doubt people are getting out their credit cards and filling out a donation form because they can't figure out out how to close a modal.
- kristopolous 11y agoSure! You can decrease the amount of time people engage with your content, antagonise your users, and get 0.01% more of the user base to convergence with donations (these are the common numbers I see) Either these things aren't looked at holistically or they are and people don't care about user experience. Think about it, you have to do this using CSS because all the browsers block doing the same functionality with another window. Once you start asking questions like "how many exits happened at dialog versus how much convergence?" you will, as I have, see ~60x more exits from service then engagement with dialog. You lose 6,000% more than you gain. And yes, the engagement is so low on most analysis that you can't dismiss marginal user error in many of the cases as constituting a large percentage of engagement. We can do better
- emodendroket 11y agoHow? Do you have a suggestion for raising revenue that's as effective? Lots of nonprofits struggle because they're too afraid to ask people for money but it turns out if you don't ask no one donates. A pop-up or -under window and a modal dialog are also different in that the modal is confined to the window or tab it exists in and when you leave the page you're on it goes away.
- kristopolous 11y agowikipedia has done a lot of research on this. Their method doesn't block content, doesn't force the user to interact with a dialog, and isn't perennial. If the website is honestly just a bunch of scraped content which solely exists to solicit donations then go ahead. But if there is another purpose, any other one, than the popup dialog detracts from it in an unnecessarily injurious way.
- fineman 11y agoI think this ignores long-term readership. Most uneducated users know how to close the entire tab and hate spam. So you'll keep getting 0.2% of an ever-smaller and more-confused set of users. In the meantime, the rest of us will learn to write greasemonkey rules for those popovers and the next generation of adblockers will evolve.