6 ms·
As a person who grew up in a place where discrimination based on gender/age/race was not really a thing, this strikes me as insane! This really does feel like d
by dmitrygr 11y ago
As a person who grew up in a place where discrimination based on gender/age/race was not really a thing, this strikes me as insane! This really does feel like discrimination, just in the opposite direction.
Is it some sort of a conspiracy here to not discuss this that I am not aware of? Or is discrimination towards some OK but not towards others?
- dmitrygr 11y agoHOLY HELL: The website, LITERALLY, says: At this time, our platform is only open to individuals who identify as Black, Hispanic/Latino, and Native American. I wonder if I could sue because I am now being discriminated against? Funnier yet, they make you pick gender between "male" and "female"....no other options... And further... The birth year selection box only goes down to 1950, so nobody over a certain age either... Very diverse, guys....
- frankdenbow 11y ago"As a person who grew up in a place where discrimination based on gender/age/race was not really a thing, this strikes me as insane!" It would behoove you to first try to empathize with those who did live in these kinds of places & learn about the history of education & discrimination in America. Then you may have some better perspective on why there are systemic reasons for why the diversity numbers for technology companies is so low (and maybe you would get an idea of why thats even important).
- dmitrygr 11y ago"history" == "past" how can you ever move on if you keep dragging it up? Hire the best. Simple. Efficient. Legal. This company's operation is probably illegal (see parent post where i listed examples of how they discriminate)
- frankdenbow 11y agoPast gives context as to why the present is as it is. Agree that its not something to dwell on. Also, agree with you about hiring the best. One of the issues this startup (I presume) is hoping to solve is to help source great candidates that may not be as well aware of their options in startups or are outside the typical silicon valley friends of friends networks that much of the hiring goes through. There are other issues like giving students the affordance of entering into the technology world (which is why I am on the board of a computer science high school) that Jopwell and others will try to aid in as well.
- comex 11y agoTo the extent the CEO's claim about a "lack of exposure" is correct, it's entirely possible that separately reaching out to minority candidates will help find "the best". If nothing else, the job market (in Silicon Valley, and elsewhere) is intensely affected by the human social network it's embedded in - it's who you know, and both the natural dynamics of a graph with sparser connections between certain groups than within them, and the instinctive aversion people have to getting to know people that aren't like them (easily overcomeable in the right situation, obviously, but everpresent), make it harder for a minority candidate to have the right connections.
- justizin 11y agoI'll add that minority candidates, including women and members of the LGBTQ+ community are often concerned about tokenization, and this can create a barrier for even the most well-meaning teams of mostly white mostly straight mostly males. Some weeks ago at SF City Hall I heard some passionate teens and teachers from the Mission talking about their frustration with having Latino cultural education cut in favor of technology education intended largely to grant them token spots at tech companies. In the east bay, I know there are networks of minorities trying to home-grow startups rather than line up to be someone's diversity hire, and while people are up in arms about this team being not terribly visually diverse, it may be built by people who understand the complex challenges of members of their own communities, including having businesses that don't have models which prey on them.
- tobin 11y agoYou say "dragging it up", I think "a reminder that we can do better". History is useful for understanding the present situation and trajectory. It gives us context. I can't speculate whether or not the practices of this site are illegal as I am not a lawyer, however I can say that it's addressing a very visible problem in hiring practices that are discriminatory. People may not be knowingly discriminating, but it certainly does happen. Often malice and incompetence cause the same results. I for one think this is great for not only building an equal opportunity for everyone in the industry, but it also broadens the accessible talent pool.
- gargarplex 11y agoAre you looking to make a career move?
- jbapple 11y ago> This company's operation is probably illegal (see parent post where i listed examples of how they discriminate) Are you a lawyer? Discrimination law in the US is very complex. If you're not a lwayer, and you're really interested in this, it might be worth your time to ask a lawyer who specializes in these things their opinion on this. One of the things that makes these things so complicated is that there isn't just one controlling authority called "the law". There are local, state, and federal laws, there are regulatory interpretations of the laws, and there are court decisions about the laws. There are also decisions by regulatory agencies about what the're going to enforce.
- DanBC 11y agoIt's not that complicated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1964 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1964 See especially this: http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/fs-race.html http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/fs-race.html > Even though race and color clearly overlap, they are not synonymous. Thus, color discrimination can occur between persons of different races or ethnicities, or between persons of the same race or ethnicity. Although Title VII does not define “color,” the courts and the Commission read “color” to have its commonly understood meaning – pigmentation, complexion, or skin shade or tone. Thus, color discrimination occurs when a person is discriminated against based on the lightness, darkness, or other color characteristic of the person. Title VII prohibits race/color discrimination against all persons, including Caucasians. EDIT: I think this service is a good idea. I'd be interested why a quote from a US government equal opportunities site got downvotes.
- jbapple 11y ago> It's not that complicated. I find it fairly complicated. Are you a lawyer? I am not. Immediately after the portion of the EEOC page you quote, there appears the text: "Although a plaintiff may prove a claim of discrimination through direct or circumstantial evidence, some courts take the position that if a white person relies on circumstantial evidence to establish a reverse discrimination claim, he or she must meet a heightened standard of proof. The Commission, in contrast, applies the same standard of proof to all race discrimination claims, regardless of the victim’s race or the type of evidence used. In either case, the ultimate burden of persuasion remains always on the plaintiff. Employers should adopt 'best practices' to reduce the likelihood of discrimination and to address impediments to equal employment opportunity." Even if you ignore the complexity directly in that section (which courts? what is the heightened standard? why do courts and the EEOC interpret things differently? what are the consequences of that difference?), there are numerous other complexities not covered by the question of "are Caucasian/white people covered?". I was not trying to say that the question of whether white people are covered is simple, but that the question of which discrimination (encompassing much more) is complicated. For instance, this service is not discriminating in who they employ, only in who they serve. Is that legal? Under what circumstances? Do laws other than the Civil Rights Act of 1964 apply? How does this law interact with the right of expressive association? (for instance, presumably, the government does not try to force churches to hire non-Christians as ministers or priests and does not try to force the KKK to admit the people they hate based on race or religion - how does that exception work under the Civil rights Act of 1964?) Does Jopwell have fewer than 15 employees, and does that make it exempt from the CRAo1964? I have heard that this law does not apply to members of Congress hiring staffers or to the Supreme Court hiring clerks - is that correct, and if so, under what provision of the law? How does it apply to college admissions? Do any of the following constitute "color" under the law: sunburning, vitiligo, albinism, tattoos, hair color, baldness, eye color? Even just the section of the Wikipedia page you link to that discusses employment discrimination includes at least a dozen caveats and extensions, along with multiple SCOTUS cases: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1964#Title_VII https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1964#Title... Also, as I mentioned, even if a certain type of discrimination may not violate federal law, it might violate state or local law. These things that I have just said are all aimed at supporting my claim that discrimination law in the US is complicated.
- gkop 11y agoAccording to your website, you are a young, white male, Google engineer, that lives in California and owns a plane. You really have nothing to worry about.
- woah 11y agoDid he say he had something to worry about?
- xacaxulu 11y agoSweeping generalizations based on race and gender aren't helpful in this discussion. He is I'm sure a complex and multifaceted individual, just like we all are.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoI think dmitrygr is being unduly dismissive and, like a lot of commenters, ought to take more time to understand. Nevertheless, you can't attack someone personally like this on HN, regardless of how wrong they may be.
- gkop 11y agoI appreciate your work encouraging civility and positivity on HN, dang. Would you elaborate here a bit please? dmitrygr said "I wonder if I could sue because I am now being discriminated against?" Can you answer this without considering dmitrygr?
- dang 11y agoI'm afraid I don't understand the question. Edit: oh, I get it now. Regardless of what one thinks of his argument, it was clear what dmitrygr meant by that, so those personal details didn't add any necessary information. Meanwhile, the damage caused by using someone else's personal details as ammunition is a big deal. We can't allow that to become a thing—nothing would destroy the discourse faster. So, from a moderation point of view: low benefit, high cost, bad idea.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I wonder if I could sue because I am now being discriminated against? Sure, you can sue for any reason at all. Whether you can win a lawsuit (or even get it past an early demurrer or motion to dismiss) is a different question.
- SandersAK 11y agoI didn't see a box saying "anyone who has a myopic entitled view of the world, and has spent their life reaping the benefits of discrimination while blindly passing off attempts to move forward because such attempts strike deep at the core of their own anxiety about their self-worth and the foundation of their success" on there so I think you're good.
- NateLawson 11y agoThis is a company that is working very hard to provide an ADDITIONAL source of candidates, emphasizing traditionally under-represented groups. If it helps you any, put it in a different context: think about a recruiting firm focused on helping small-town Americans. They would put you in their job pool if you live in a town that has less than 25,000 people or whatever. Would you make the same complaints about that service? Good companies will ALWAYS source candidates from many possible routes. The worst companies now are the ones that only hire friends and family or people with "culture fit" (often thinly veiled term for "reminds me of me"). Those are not hiring from a very large pool. There is no company doing the opposite ("I will only hire people not referred by friends"), and to complain about a possible straw man future where Jopwell becomes a monopoly, putting Dice, Craigslist, and every individual recruiter out of business is laughably easy to dismiss. I haven't looked at Hacker News much recently, and I had a self-imposed 2 year ban on visiting it that I kept to until then. Comments like this are literally making me tear up and wish I hadn't come back. :(
- eropple 11y agoI'm in the same boat, honestly. The amount of venal regressiveness--the obvious resentment and sexism any time anything's being done to target women to get them into the industry, stuff like this--is really disheartening. I've spoken offline to dang about this and I think his heart's in the right place but I'm so very bummed out right now. It's gotten to the point where most of my friends go "ugh, why do you still read that slop?" and my only remotely defensible answer is "because somebody should argue against the horrible shit that gets said." That's not much of a reason.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> As a person who grew up in a place where discrimination based on gender/age/race was not really a thing, this strikes me as insane! It would be insane in a place where discrimination based on gender/age/race hadn't been a thing for so long that it substantially distorts all aspects of society. However, the place where its actually developed and focused isn't that kind of place, so that doesn't really matter.
- akc 11y agothat "place" you refer to - are you speaking about your early days in Russia, or the US? Because I assure you discrimination is alive and well in both places.
- dang 11y agoI don't believe you were deliberately trolling, but on reflection, I do think your comments in this thread have broken the HN guidelines [1], which say: "Please avoid introducing classic flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say about them." You didn't engage with anything specific about this story. You only raised the most automatic and generic and obvious of objections, in an outraged tone. That's precisely what that guideline asks you not do to. Moreover, you got some really thoughtful replies that (agree or not) were clearly trying to answer you meaningfully. But you responded with more automatic dismissals (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9893128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9893128). That is not substantive discussion. I'm impressed (edit: and grateful!) that frankdenbow and the other users replying to you stayed as respectful and thoughtful as they did. HN is a public forum; the public is divided; we can't expect everyone to agree. We can, though, expect you to actually engage with others, with the real problems they're working on or facing, and ask questions and listen to replies in good faith. Respectful disagreement on a divisive topic is hard enough when people do meet this standard; it's impossible when they don't. One violation can blow an entire crater in the discussion. Please don't do that again. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html