2 ms·
Some of it's that and some of it's the fact that he's addressing different arguments, and from somewhat shifted political perspectives Both Krugman's quoted pa
by notahacker 11y ago
Some of it's that and some of it's the fact that he's addressing different arguments, and from somewhat shifted political perspectives
Both Krugman's quoted passages acknowledge that conventional economic theory would tend to suggest that minimum wages reduce the size of the work place, but both labour economists' theories of labour supply and some empirical work suggests that this isn't universally the case, especially where increases are small. Neither say very much on the subject.
But the 1998 one is attacking a book which (according to Krugman) suggests that compelling employers to pay more - 57% more in the example - will reduce welfare costs and have no adverse effect on employment
The recent article attacks a more general view that wage reduction is essential to get the nation's economy out of a rut, and is particularly approving of quasi market-based mechanisms to raise minimum wages (trade unions and Walmart's justification in terms of efficiency wages)
It's the political line of argument rather than the use of economic theory that has changed (and given that Krugman doesn't exactly pull his punches, it's not surprising that one article reads almost like an attack on the other). He's not having to turn his back on economic theory to argue that the US would be better off if minimum wages were a little higher, and it wasn't slavish devotion to economic theory that caused him to contest what he described as a "moral" argument for wage regulation over redistribution from Pollin and Lice.