3 ms·
Not as simple at all. I can teach people how to write software pretty quick. Those same people might take years to learn to make working hardware. Without exten
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Not as simple at all. I can teach people how to write software pretty quick. Those same people might take years to learn to make working hardware. Without extensive tool support, it can take them a lot longer as process nodes they work on get smaller. And you don't know if it works until you shell out big money for an ASIC prototype and probably do several iterations of that.
The fact that you have to spend more money to test the design is the biggest difference. Eliminate all the rest with brilliant, well studied people and you still have that huge cost on a decent process node. Services such as MOSIS help but only so much. Open-source, gate-level testing and general verification tools would be a great investment in that they reduce this significantly. Well, a full suite of open source (or cheap) EDA tools in general would be nice but that's a whole different, pessimistic discussion. :(
- minthd 11y ago>> Well, a full suite of open source (or cheap) EDA tools in general would be nice but that's a whole different, pessimistic discussion. :( Actually for the leading edge - the cost of EDA tools is among the largest bottlenecks ,possibly even stopping moore's law - through greatly reducing design starts and breaking the economics of the law.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's one point in the pessimistic discussion. Worse that most of the tools hit NP-hard problems whose solutions leverage a combination of public knowledge, esoteric wisdom (often trade secret), and many PhD's worth of algorithms. It's going to be... really hard... to duplicate them plus their results in proprietary or FOSS. Personally, I'd just suggest Bill Gates or another fat cat buy Mentor (cheapest) then dual-license their stuff and offer discounts for early years to startups. Or discount + royalty strategy. Results might get very interesting in terms of innovation.
- minthd 11y agoPersonally i wouldn't interrupt Bill Gates. He's doing amazing stuff. But it could really appeal to other philanthropists who seek recognition and impact. Another idea i had in that area - why won't great scientists collaboratively start an open DARPA - creating propositions for truly breakthrough science/engineering projects - and letting philanthropists buy and make them happen ? Assuming philanthropists get at least one success from a few trials - it's guaranteed impact - on a very large scale.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThing is, what individual or small group of them could I convince to spend almost $2 billion? Bill Gates has plenty more than that and would understand the value of the purchase. He's also trying to give away most of his fortune. Weren't any other names that popped into my mind. Suggestions?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoPerhaps it's context? I certainly agree that teaching someone chip design is a long process, so is teaching them to design a compiler. For me, it is a level of complexity which cannot be abstracted against. So, for example, it is easy to teach middle school kids to make working digital circuits out of TTL gates, but much harder to teach them how to bias a transistor amplifier to operate in its linear region. Similarly its easy to teach them basic game mechanics with PyGame or something similar but harder to teach them out to develop inverse kinematics and shader based rendering in the Unity engine. All about scale. For me the big difference is that you see a program that does something, and if you're skilled enough write your own version that does the same thing, even if it was protected by copyright you "own" that new code you wrote. But if you saw some hardware that did something, and were skilled enough to implement that same thing yourself, if it was protected by patent, you couldn't share your version. Sad really. Even an open source RISC cpu couldn't be built with out of order execution until those patents[1] expired. But now a lot of those patents are expiring and so its a great time to be in the bespoke hardware business. [1] https://www.google.com/patents/US5666506 https://www.google.com/patents/US5666506
- sliverstorm 11y agoAre you sure about that last part? I thought whitebox engineering was completely acceptable in hardware. Additionally the patent says: A method of issuing and executing instructions out-of-order in a pipelined microprocessor in a single processor cycle... In other words, it's hardly a patent on OoO.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMost of the OoO patents are lapsed. This one is recent: http://www.freepatentsonline.com/y2015/0026442.html http://www.freepatentsonline.com/y2015/0026442.html Who knows what it's patent status is. One can always do an in-order design. Has the advantage of determinism and ease of covert channel analysis.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI think scale matters but so does complexity. Do you really think someone building TTL circuits will be able to do a 48nm design without EDA that's useful for something? Stuff quickly gets out of control to the point that designers depend on tools to catch all the problems. I can use a method such as Cleanroom, basic abstraction, and a homebrew Oberon/BASIC/LISP to design software of about any size on the market's cheapest PC. The ASIC's? I'm going to be begging for synthesis (RTL at the least) & place-and-route before the day is up on a non-toy project. The patent vs copyright law issue is huge. It's one of the reasons I haven't tried to bring a solution to market: can't defend the lawsuit and don't want to take one down. I thought on it a long time to try to determine a way to reduce risk. https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/03/friday_squid_bl_415.html#c4873983 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/03/friday_squid_... There's still risks as Clive Robinson notes further down. Making sure the technology is produced outside the U.S. could help. As Clive noted, there was a hardware engineer both of us talked to whose company specifically avoided the American market due to all the patent nonsense. He said they did fine without it. Corruption in Congress on the issue means it's not changing anytime soon.