2 ms·
It isn't irrational, it is emotional. The difference being that people have a harder time reasoning about their emotions than they do about facts (or even the f
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
It isn't irrational, it is emotional. The difference being that people have a harder time reasoning about their emotions than they do about facts (or even the facts that lead to the emotions).
I've had similar conversations with people about radiation, I've pointed them to the excellent radiation chart, and I've gone over papers and articles and data galore. But if they are afraid, they are afraid. And deciding not to be afraid is often challenging. It is no different than people who are afraid of germs and are incessantly cleaning their living spaces or sanitizing their dishes in an autoclave. They know germs can kill them, they know they can't see or feel or taste germs they might be ingesting or coming into contact with, so they spend all sorts of time and energy on eliminating germs.
Is it irrational? No, not in the strict sense, germs really can kill them. Is it emotional? Absolutely there is a very real fear response there. Is it proportional to the threat? No, and that is where folks need to have a discussion in terms of proportion rather than real / not-real or threat / not-threat.
- athenot 11y agoIt is very similar to the emotions stirred up by a plane crash vs. the ongoing car accidents. I believe in both cases it comes down to not feeling in control. As a population, we over-estimate our ability to safely drive cars. Yet because we are in control, we FEEL safer than being in a plane where, should anything go wrong, we'd be totally powerless as we descend to our doom. Most of us have a general grasp on how a fire is put out, or how a dam is repaired, or how an oil well is fixed. But this invisible thing called radiation, which is used in the most powerful bombs ever made and which appears to be near incontrollable because it deals with the very structure of matter, this radiation ends up associated with a very powerful fear.
- Retra 11y agoIrrational means that the fear is not proportional to the risk, not that there is a fear of something that poses no risk. It is irrational to possess a fear of radiation in lieu of other things that pose a far greater threat.