4 ms·
Considering Instacart now offers its couriers an option to sign up as employees, I'd be curious to see how many take them up on that offer. A part-time employe
by prostoalex 11y ago
Considering Instacart now offers its couriers an option to sign up as employees, I'd be curious to see how many take them up on that offer.
A part-time employee status (vs contractor) generally comes with loss of control over one's working hours, 30-hour weekly caps (to avoid the ACA penalty), and compensation setup that involves some kind of (likely minimum) wage + bonus instead of straight-up 1099 income.
Most of the gig economy (Uber, TaskRabbit, PostMates) is built around flexibility of hours, and freedom to not only accept a gig, but to refuse one (which you lose if you're in an employer-employee relationship and the boss is simply assigning it to you).
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoDoesn't Uber ban you if you don't accept almost all fares? The problem with this models is that you're not really an independent contractor - you're simply on-demand casual labour. The Internet element makes it unnecessary to stand outside the factory gates every morning, which is certainly a benefit. But all the obligations remain one way. You have to accept the work, but if you decide to take time out you can be "fired" from the system without notice, at will, at random, and with zero come-back against the "employer."
- chipgap98 11y agoI think with Uber you can control when you do and do not show up as a driver, so its choose your own hours in that sense
- s73v3r 11y agoYet, if you don't log in during off-peak hours enough, you end up getting pushed down the list, essentially being punished for not working certain hours.
- crazy1van 11y agoIn my completely unscientific survey of asking my Uber drivers how they like their job, I've never had a single one complain about their employment arrangement. Most of them talk about how much they like the flexibility to work the hours they want. This is across a diverse group of drivers from young college kids, new immigrants, and semi-retirees. Is my sample set an anomaly or have others heard similar stories? If the workers in the "gig economy" really are generally happy and their employers are happy and their customers are happy, I'm not sure I see a good reason to toss new regulations into the mix.
- x0x0 11y agodid it cross your mind that they may not bitch about their job to a person who can fire them (you)? If their rating falls below 4, they are essentially canned by uber. Also, there's plenty of room for regulation even if customers and employees are happy. Uber is a giant negative externality, and we should force them to internalize it.
- seanflyon 11y ago> Uber is a giant negative externality Could you elaborate on this?
- hayksaakian 11y agoUber drivers who are unhappy probably leave uber more often than if they were happy. Therefore any random driver is more likely to enjoy uber instead of disliking uber.
- beat 11y agoRight. That's a grain of salt I take when I talk to Uber drivers. That said, I've had several drivers who were former taxi drivers, and much prefer working for Uber. Here in Minneapolis, the taxi driver business is dominated by our large (30k+) Somali community. I'm starting to see Somalis and Kenyans more as drivers now, when just a year ago they tended to be caucasian. This tells me Uber is making a real dent in the taxi driver employee base.
- olefoo 11y agoI think you underestimate how powerful the rating system is on the behavior of the people who serve you on a day to day basis is. It's quite possible that Uber drivers do not want to give you any reason to give a negative rating, including being open about their actual feelings about the economic arrangements that govern their relationship to you.
- baddox 11y agoI have a friend I met completely outside of Uber who is a full-time Uber driver. He says he loves driving, meeting all sorts of people, and choosing his own hours. It's obviously just one anecdote, but I'm pretty sure he's not lying.
- prostoalex 11y agoThe driver explicitly made himself available in the system, but the choice of hours and choice of location to idle by is still up to the driver. With employee relationship, Uber can mandate the driver be by the football arena at 6 pm.
- matthewowen 11y agoBut if you want to work at hours convenient to you, then you probably won't make much money. Most people aren't out driving people to the airport at 5am for the fun of it. For people who drive Uber as a primary source of income, sure there's some notional freedom. But in practical terms, there are times that you can productively work at and times that you can't. Same thing goes for PostMates.
- prostoalex 11y agoSo in other words, the flexibility of those hours stays roughly equal. If someone is relying on Uber for their primary source of income, the 30-hour cap might be a definite turn-off. Now, it's not a given that Uber will institute that, but I think the way the laws are worded in this country every single part-time employer has that policy just to avoid future liabilities.
- s73v3r 11y agoExcept, as has been shown time and again, people who take advantage of that flexibility end up being punished, making the flexibility not really flexible. Uber, for instance, will stop offering you gigs if you turn too many down, or don't drive often enough during peak hours.