2 ms·"A did X" is not refuted by "B would have done X too if B were in A's place."by mikeash 11y ago"A did X" is not refuted by "B would have done X too if B were in A's place."meragrin 11y agoHow is "wouldn't have happened without him being in office" the same as "A did X"?mikeash 11y agoI took that as meaning that either the seat was occupied by a rock, or perhaps by McCain.