5 ms·
People chanting "USA" are literally not saying "in your face, my country is better that yours." I think if that's what you're hearing, you're bringing some pers
by snowwrestler 11y ago
People chanting "USA" are literally not saying "in your face, my country is better that yours." I think if that's what you're hearing, you're bringing some personal interpretation to your hearing.
- scrollaway 11y agoIt's not what I'm hearing, and you probably missed my point. It's alienating and very shallow. Like I said, there's nothing wrong with being proud of one's country's, or a country's achievements. There's nothing wrong with being proud of your government, of your people, of your land. But turn that into mindless yelling and that's just a pissing contest. It's ignorant of what other countries have to bring. To give you a concrete example: I'm french. There's a lot of things I'm not proud of from my country. I'm proud of my language; French is beautiful. But I also make an effort to learn the language of every country I live in. I have fallen in love with Swedish. Had I been in a pissing match telling everybody (but mostly myself) how amazing French is, would I have gotten the chance to learn any other language? Would I have gotten the chance to even write my thoughts, in English, on this very forum? This is a relevant example because, in France, a lot of people have that attitude of being too proud to learn another language. It's one of the recurring tourist complaints about France, in fact! I see this as no different.
- Retric 11y agoIf you have ever been to a high school pep rally; most people don’t actually care about the school. But, it’s fun to stand up and yell really loudly. Nationalism is IMO deeper than that. To use a EU example, many people in Greece complain about countries that are giving them money. “How dare they attach strings when handing us money!!!” That’s nationalist in ways I have trouble understanding.
- david-given 11y agoSpeaking as a UK citizen living in Switzerland, I have to ask: what is a high school pep rally?
- Retric 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pep_rally https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pep_rally It's really just a time filler to cover the gap between when classes end and a school game begins. Growing up in the US I think we had ~1 or 2 per year from ~8th-12th grade. They were also generally fairly short as in 10-15 minutes with I think one lasting 45 when the other team was late. PS: Most games did not take place during the school day, but I think they scheduled a few that with a small overlap if a team would otherwise get home really late during a week night. I think there much more common in low density areas for this reason. Edit: Though like all such traditions it's been morphing for a while. With some schools holding them before big events and or in the middle of the day.
- david-given 11y agoFrankly, that sounds pretty creepy --- it looks to me like an outright indoctrination session. I couldn't imagine my school in Scotland doing anything similar (and we were a very sporty school, with compulsory attendance at a lot of inter-school games, which I mostly sneaked away from).
- mturmon 11y agoYou are in for a treat. This excerpt from Fast Times at Ridgemont High (worth watching in its entirety) tells you what you need to know: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLTTugZ4BIw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLTTugZ4BIw
- pluma 11y agoWhat you seem to miss is that Americans chanting "USA" is so frequent and so common even in situations that wouldn't be considered to warrant any nationalism by anyone else that it's a point of ridicule by anyone else. Case in point, this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhITpTtG888 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhITpTtG888
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoPlease, keep explaining America to us. Most of the socially liberal Americans consider it just as ridiculous and it is regularly parodied in our media all the time. I especially love that you dug up an obviously ironic chant by college students at the presence of a bald eagle and cited it as if it meant something. The bald eagle is our national symbol and is so over-the-top American that I could see the joke immediately, but I guess I understand how it would be lost on a European. That you take that video seriously is hilarious. There's something I could counter relating to certain European tendencies to explain the world to the world since certain parts of Europe still consider most of the planet as belonging to them, but I won't, because this isn't the thread or the place. Did everybody in this thread wake up today and say "gosh, I'm going to argue about America in a thread about Pluto, that's my achievement for the day"?
- mturmon 11y agoI admit, that's laughable (and I did get an honest laugh, and upvoted you for the pleasure), but that was taken at Oral Roberts University, which is a fundamentalist college founded by one of the most notorious ex-Pentecostal televangelists my fair nation has ever produced. And that's saying something. In other words, about as representative of Americans as a Le Pen rally is about French. [Contra another comment nearby: due to the venue, I believe it was a genuine chant, not ironic, although probably a bit giddy. If it had been a more mainstream university, I agree, that would have definitely been a goofy ironic chant.]