4 ms·
Have you read the Iran deal? The Iranians were happy about it, this it likely wasn't a good deal for the rest of us. The Iranians can't be trusted. If Obama car
by briandear 11y ago
Have you read the Iran deal? The Iranians were happy about it, this it likely wasn't a good deal for the rest of us. The Iranians can't be trusted. If Obama cares about Iran, he would have supported their Green Revolution; instead those protestors were executed, tortured or imprisioned. Yet, strangely, Obama supported the Egyptian coup. Honestly, Obama doesn't know what he's doing when it comes to foreign policy. He sort of waddles along weakening the U.S. position whenever possible.
- rayiner 11y agoRevolution is almost always a bad thing for liberal democracy. See, e.g., the Arab Spring, the 1979 Iranian Revolution. Had those protestors been successful, there is a significant possibility would have been co-opted by elements that executed, tortured, and imprisoned a lot more people. See, e.g., the French Revolution. Iran, in contrast, is well on its way to having a functional democracy. The power of the ayatollah wanes every year, and every new generation of young Iranians is more liberal than before. The best thing the U.S. can do is be friendly and wait for that to play out. Because if there is any hope for another democracy in the Middle East, it's in a place where people are already accustomed to the benefits of having a functioning government with significant and growing public participation.
- toyg 11y ago> The Iranians can't be trusted. National stereotypes, pillars of pragmatic diplomacy ever since 2000 BC and the clear mark of logical thinkers the world over. > If Obama cares about Iran, he would have supported their Green Revolution How do you know he didn't? Because he didn't send in bombers to "support demonstrations"? > Yet, strangely, Obama supported the Egyptian coup ... when the alternative would have been much more Iran-friendly; yeah, how strange, right? Honestly, how do you make these random mental associations? > He sort of waddles along weakening the U.S. position whenever possible. A comprehensive Iran-US 'peace deal' (or even a strategic partnership going forward) would immensely strengthen US standing around the world, dramatically reducing tensions in the Middle East and providing a balance to the uncritical reliance on Saudi Arabia and Turkey that so much pain has brought since the '90s (from Al Qaeda to IS). So uhm, there is that. But yeah, I agree that it weakens fearmongers' positions, both in US, Israel and Iran.
- seivan 11y agoUS reliance on Turkey is just a strategic position against Russia. You're a fool for thinking any deal with Iran will bring something like that to the Table. Your blind faith is incredibly disturbing.
- toyg 11y ago> US reliance on Turkey is just a strategic position against Russia. It's a strategic position against everyone. Look at the map and tell me what other NATO bases you can use to dominate Middle-Eastern airspace if you lose Turkey (after having basically lost Saudi Arabia without gaining really-secure positions in Iraq and Afghanistan). Until we invent bombers with unlimited mileage, Turkey is a required ally in the region. > You're a fool [...] Your blind faith is incredibly disturbing. That's ironic, considering faith is the one thing I've always sorely lacked. But thanks for the name-calling.
- rqebmm 11y ago> Look at the map and tell me what other NATO bases you can use to dominate Middle-Eastern airspace I think this is precisely why there's been such a huge buildup of the airbase in Erbil. Granted, that wasn't a viable option a little while ago. It's going to be interesting watching the US try to pull the "roommate swap" between Turkey and the Kurds.
- dang 11y agoThis and your previous comment break the HN guidelines. Please don't post comments unless they are both civil and substantive. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mason240 11y ago>> The Iranians can't be trusted. >National stereotypes, pillars of pragmatic diplomacy ever since 2000 BC and the clear mark of logical thinkers the world over. The OP clearly means the theocratic regime, not the Iranian people themselves.
- amalag 11y agoAre the republicans really that dumb that if they see Iran telling their people "It is a great deal for us" they think they are telling them the truth. Guess what, they have to spin deals to their public too.