3 ms·
It's not like any other announcement. Is that a bad thing?
by baby 11y ago
It's not like any other announcement. Is that a bad thing?
- tom_mellior 11y agoWell IMHO the whole "I had no idea what I was doing and it was really difficult to figure out that in the emulator memory-mapped registers must be (gasp!) mapped to memory, and Tom's mansplanation didn't help" doesn't exactly inspire a lot of confidence.
- tptacek 11y agoWhat are you talking about? That's not what she said. She pointed out that the stack pointer is a I/O register, which was in fact so weird that we did in fact argue about it (she was right, I was wrong). Why did she write about that? I don't know, perhaps because people who participate in Microcorruption are going to program AVR stack pointers? "Mansplanation"? Really? It feels like no matter what someone writes --- an emulator, a TCP/IP stack, a Montgomery curve implementation, the world's fastest SMT solver, whatever --- there is always somebody, who always writes like they sound like "that creepy booger-nosed kid" from King of the Hill, to tell us how unimpressive the accomplishment is. Thanks, Clark Peters! You've struck again!
- tom_mellior 11y ago> What are you talking about? That's not what she said. She pointed out that the stack pointer is a I/O register, which was in fact so weird that we did in fact argue about it (she was right, I was wrong). Yes, that's what I'm talking about, and that is what she said: You argued about something that is a fact (and well-documented) and thus simply not up for argument. Previously I thought you were a group of experienced professionals with a proven track record of delivering great stuff. That made me pretty confident that Starfighter would be awesome. With this announcement that explains how you all did new stuff without building on that experience and it came out kinda crappy and buggy, haha, my confidence is diminished. I don't expect you to agree, but that is my impression from what I can gather from this announcement.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoThat's an interesting point. My answer, in three parts: 1. Meat-loaf. 2. Beat-loaf. 3. I hate meat-loaf.