4 ms·
Why is it that nobody in the Eurozone is willing to discuss the fundamental and disastrous consequences of a unified monetary policy with independent fiscal pol
by jandrese 11y ago
Why is it that nobody in the Eurozone is willing to discuss the fundamental and disastrous consequences of a unified monetary policy with independent fiscal policy?
Are we going to wait until Greece has to be bailed out a fourth time? Or a fifth time? What about when Spain defaults? This is going to keep on happening until the underlying problems are addressed. Ultimately, the EU is going to need the ability to tax and spend to redistribute wealth and keep the economies working. It's the same way the US taxes New York, Massachusetts, California, etc... to give to Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and so on.
I know it will be unpopular politically, but the EU really needs to make itself look more like the United States of Europe if it wants this whole unified currency thing to work. They have been trying to ignore the elephant in the room for so long that smaller countries are drowning in its shit.
- cristianpascu 11y agoThe elephant in the room can not be that big since it could enter through the door. The EU project is nothing like US. This is the XIX, with all the economical and political complications. And we're talking about a bunch of very different countries and cultures. You don't just throw them together in a bowl and stir. USofE is a solution to a problem created by a solution that was not needed in the first place. It was an ideal. It still is. The ideal of a few that got to be shared by more and more people. But not by everyone, not with any cost.
- nickik 11y agoYou are right, exept when you say that the EU needs to make itself more like the US. If people actually want that, then we might want to do so. However not a single country will vote for this. So if you don't want to force it one people, then this will not work.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, especially in border regions such stuff is popular – the people living at the border between Denmark and Sweden, or the Netherlands and Belgium would prefer more unification, as for them every bit of independence of these countries means a less convenient life.
- nickik 11y agoMinmal amount of people live along the border. You can get most of the benefit without a political union. Free movment of goods and people can be done with bilateral agreements. No need for the EU.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, it’s not just that: For the people in border regions – which, if you take Denmark (50% of the population), the Netherlands (100%), Belgium (100%) are especially in small countries a high percentage – it’s important to be able to live in the other country as if it were your own. Free ability to live, work, retire, buy stuff, sell stuff, etc is extremely important. For this to work, though, you need a common currency (imagine you work in Germany and live in Denmark, now the exchange rate changes, and your money is only worth half of the original value, and you suddenly can’t pay your rent anymore), you need simplified tax systems (imagine the mess of working in Germany, living in the netherlands, having your funds in Luxembourg, and owning a second house in Belgium). The EU guarantuees all this. It also helps with unified travel, with unified conservation of natural resources – take the UNESCO World Natural Heritage Site of the wadden sea – it reaches into 3 countries and the EU had a great deal in making it happen. For someone living in a border region, the EU is necessary for survival. No, the EU can not be undone, we need to get even closer. In my state, policemen of Denmark and Germany are on patrol together to make cross-border crimes easier to process – because it means you always have one with authority, even if you end up arresting them in the other country. We recently made Danish an official language in my state even. A family member of mine works as a public facing official in a governmental institution here and has to deal with people filing forms in German, Dutch, English and Danish every day. In some cities in the border regions, up to half of the population works on the other side of the border! No, the EU can not be undone.
- nickik 11y agoNon of the things you say, need to EU to work. You are setting up a false choice between central control and chaos. I happen to live in Switzerland, and I know many people who work in Switzerland or Germany and work in the other country. This is perfeclty simple and workable. Countries can agree on how taxes work without a central control from brussel. You can make bilateral agreements about Individual problems. This will get you 95% of the benefits and you avoid the majority of the cost. You know like that little tiny problem were the hole of the Eurozone is suffering economicly and the society of greece is disintegrating. I guess fuck the problem of the greeks, let them suffer, its much more important for me to be able to buy cheap petrol on the other side of the border.
- vinceguidry 11y agoThe EU is not a collection of states, it's an association of countries. Such a fundamental change to the nature of the political arrangement would be not just unpopular, but completely unprecedented. You'd be essentially turning all of Europe into one country. Taxation is one of those things people have very very strong feelings about, enough to go to war over. Maybe in a few hundred years the EU might be cohesive enough for such a drastic political alteration. For now rectifying the problems caused by the currency union through the abysmally-slow process of international diplomacy is going to have to suffice. What's nice about Schengen is that at least those who are too-adversely affected can (relatively) easily move to another country with more opportunities.
- jandrese 11y agoThis is the problem though. They're pretending that they're all unified, and have built a monetary system on that fantasy, while in fact they are all still independent. It is an inherently unstable situation, and we can expect a steady string of financial crises until something is changed. The latest Greek bailout is just another example of them kicking the can down the road. No problems were solved, none of the underlying issues were addressed, it's going to be a problem again in a few months. On the other hand, it looks like everybody at the table knows that the current agreement is a joke. Did you see the timetable on the massive reforms Greece is supposed to implement? They've given themselves like 3 days to completely turn their economy around. And on the European side the agreement basically says "We'll maybe consider maybe extending the payback period if you succeed in completely reforming yourself by the end of the week." It's not even a funny joke.
- fla 11y agoIt will never be like the US because Europe countries don't share a single language / culture, nor a common history. The engineer in me really feels safer having many small independant systems than a single mega unified thing that is too big to fail - but it's another story.
- jandrese 11y agoHaving a bunch of small systems is no good if the failure of any one system brings the whole thing down. I'm not personally convinced that a Greek exit from the Euro would be the disaster that the news outlets like to think it will be. I think it will suck for the Greeks and basically brand them as a third world country, but it is probably a better solution than a few years of crippling austerity followed by another default/bailout/more austerity. On the other hand, a Greek exit would also mean that the Eurozone countries wouldn't be forced to examine the aggregate fiscal policy and figure out a way to prevent this sort of problem from happening elsewhere.