9 ms·
Elio Motors is crowdfunding its entire $25M investment round
- trothamel 11y agoIs there any reason to think this attempt at a three-wheeled motorcycle/car would be more successful than previous iterations? It's been tried a lot in the past, but it doesn't seem to have ever really caught on. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Three-wheeled_motor_vehicles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Three-wheeled_motor_v...
- joshuapants 11y agoIt does seem likely that this could end up being Aptera Part II.
- ndonnellan 11y agoI was wondering when someone would bring that up: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aptera_Motors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aptera_Motors "As of January 2010, the number of unique deposits tracked at the unofficial Aptera forum surpassed 5000."
- obstinate 11y agoMaybe. It looks like that vehicle never even reached production. Very difficult to tell how such a vehicle would have fared in the market given that it was never tested. I mean, "could be an Aptera 3e situation" is an accusation that could be leveled at almost any first-vehicle from a company. The fact that they're both trikes is barely relevant.
- CodeWriter23 11y agoMaybe, and I do mean "maybe" the cost of vehicle ownership and fuel costs are factors that would incentivize such a purchase. I know we are a corner case, but I would consider purchasing one of these. Well, if they get some YouTube crash videos up like the SmartCar video... My family works on a "primary car / backup car" basis. Most of our combined driving needs are covered by our TDI wagon. When we infrequently both need to drive on the same day, whomever is going on the longest trip takes the TDI, and the other takes the beater. I could see a car like this replacing the beater, or becoming the car used by whomever isn't driving our daughter on a given day.
- obstinate 11y agoThere are some reasons to think so. It's fully enclosed. It might be better constructed. The price is pretty low. Fuel efficiency is good. Maybe it will, maybe it won't. Personally, I like to see marginal ideas tried again every couple of decades. An idea might click with the public in one decade that wouldn't have two before, because of changing perceptions and needs.
- tptacek 11y agoCompletely public crowd-investment in startups is a bad idea. Crowdfunding is (mostly) great, but people invest money expecting a return, and startups do not generate returns the way the stock market does. Crowdfunding as a public investment vehicle is going to hurt a lot of people.
- x5n1 11y agopeople should know what they are getting in to. if they don't, just like the normal market, that's their problem. it would be very nice to destroy the vc market, or at least give them some more competition, and also to see some of the wealth generated returned to the people rather than back in the pocket of people who already have lots of money.
- tptacek 11y agoVenture capital funds tend to underperform the market, and are subsidized by allocation requirements at their customers (pension funds, university endowments) that encourage relatively small slices of huge funds to be put into longshots and stuff that isn't correlated with lucrative investments. At least, that's what Kauffman said about it. To generate outsized returns for a small subset of investors, you don't have to be anywhere nearly as sophisticated as a VC fund: you can just run a lottery. If you want to do something more socially useful than a numbers racket, crowd-investing probably isn't the best way to go.
- pmorici 11y ago
- ealexhudson 11y agoA three-wheeler! Unfortunately in the UK this is almost certainly no-go; we've had our fill of the Sinclair / Reliant / etc. I'm really unsure about this whole 'equity crowdfunding' thing. Risky ventures are for a certain class of investor; you need a certain amount of information too. I'm all about getting public access into these things, but you really can't evaluate it on the information presented...
- mastax 11y agoTwo front, one back is much better than two back one front.
- notahacker 11y agoThat may be true, but the image problem of 3 wheelers wasn't down to any specific handling issue. And this is an image problem in a country which pays twice as much for fuel, prefers hatchbacks to pickups, and has the original Mini as a national icon.
- ams6110 11y agoRight, they just look ridiculous. Worse than the Smart car, and I didn't think that was possible outside of a circus.
- protomyth 11y agoI will say this about the Smart car, my friend who is a part-time bouncer sat in one comfortably with a lot of room. I was pretty amazed with the interior size.
- beatpanda 11y agoOne great thing about crowdfunding is that it will enable companies to raise money without having to move to the Bay Area.
- notahacker 11y agoI'd prefer it if companies were not significantly disadvantaged in fundraising outside the Bay Area because VCs had some of the ability to think outside the box they are supposedly blessed with...
- rory096 11y agoSlightly related: does anybody know how Terrafugia's Wefunder round went?
- bane 11y agoI drive an old, small car. I'm about to get in the market for a new car once this one bites the dust. In 12 years, I've put more than 2 people in my car exactly 3 times. I'm interested in reasonable price, fuel efficiency and most of all reliability. I admit I'm a little extreme in my car buying habits, but here's what I think whenever I buy cars: - Does this make model of car have extremely good reliability? I honestly can think of few things I hate more than servicing my car. I want it to be appliance-level reliable. My current car has been in the shop (outside of normal maintenance) maybe under 5 times...mostly as the vehicle has gotten old. How do I determine reliability? Years and years of compiled reliability surveys: Consumer Reports, True Delta, etc. I expect any car I buy to have been part of a legacy of at least 5 years of continuously high reliability. This immediately downselects and eliminates about 95% of the market. - If it breaks, how expensive is it to fix? To return to a reliable operating condition, I don't want to have to rebalance my entire finances. - What's the car cost to operate per mile? My current car runs around $.20-.25 per mile, fully burdened (repairs, tolls, etc.). I don't want to spend much more than that and this car could easily hit that mark if it's reliable and cheap to fix. - Is it safe? I want top safety ratings all around. Period. I'm not going to fool with that stuff. As it turns out, makers that make reliable cars tend to also make very safe cars. - Do I like how it looks/drives/etc? It may seem weird to lots of people that this is the last thing on my list. But I've already prevented any sort of decision paralysis by getting rid of 95+% of the market. At this point I'm down to just a handful of cars, and now I just pick the one I like. Now I know I'll at least not mind driving it, and it won't piss me off by being in the shop constantly. I don't really care much about the image I'm projecting, I'm not trying to fit into some kind of clique or club or express myself. I just want to get to work as cheaply as possible and with a minimum of hassle. I'll enjoy the clique I'm in when I retire with all the extra money I've saved not buying image cars. Can the Elio support this? Maybe and it looks promising. I'd buy it if it met all the criteria. The price looks awesome. But I'm going to have to be patient for 4 or 5 years of general availability to see.
- maaaats 11y agoCould an electric bicycle be something? For commutes etc. it's cheap, single person, faster than standing still in traffic, can be exercise (or not). How safe depends on where you live.
- hammerzeit 11y agoBut... why? I don't understand why an entrepreneur would prefer crowdfunded money to venture capital. And if he can't raise venture capital with the glut of money in venture right now, that's doubly worrying. The only thing that makes any sense to me at least is a marketing angle -- by getting lots of people as "shareholders" you now have a base of evangelists to advocate for your car.
- burger_moon 11y agoAt $6800 this will make for a good transplant of a poor mans t-rex[1]. Swap in a zx14r motor and you've got yourself an animal. [1] https://www.campagnamotors.com https://www.campagnamotors.com
- skeuomorf 11y agoHmm, so I wasn't able to find any technical information at all about the vehicle (engine specs, suspension, electronics...etc) neither on the linked page nor on their official website.
- kcorbitt 11y agoUnfortunately, most of the people who they're targeting for this round probably don't have the training to evaluate that type of information even if they had it. Are there any reliable third party experts who have given their opinion of the tech one way or the other? That's probably the next best thing to understanding it yourself.
- skeuomorf 11y agoExactly, I was kinda shocked at how much they've raised (via crowdfunding) given the absence of vital information.
- alganet 11y agoThere is some info in their PDF (http://www.eliomotors.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Elio_3399_One_Page_Sell_Sheet_v8_HR.pdf http://www.eliomotors.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Elio_33...). Link is available on their website.
- skeuomorf 11y agoAh, this appears to have a little more information, thanks.
- nawitus 11y ago84 mpg is a rather low number. Volkswagen Lupo 3L was about 78 mpg, but that was 15 years ago, and fuel efficient tech has advanced considerably in that time. And the Lupo was a normal 4-wheel car with a lot more space than the Elio. The Lupo 3L is probably slightly more safer, too. The Elio does beat the Lupo in price, though, but $6800 is of course an estimate.
- bagels 11y agoEuropean mpg is not the same rating as the United States mpg mostly because a gallon is not the same size everywhere, as ridiculous as that fact is. http://jalopnik.com/5981938/why-do-european-cars-get-better-mpg-than-us-cars http://jalopnik.com/5981938/why-do-european-cars-get-better-... Using your number of 78mpg imperial for the Lupo, this is only about 64mpg us.
- nawitus 11y agoIt's 78 miles per US gallon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_Lupo#Lupo_3L https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_Lupo#Lupo_3L
- ams6110 11y agoThe Lupo is not sold in the US, and this brings up something I've always wondered. Is 78 mpg calculated using imperial gallons? Because that would translate into a lower number in US gallons.
- MagnumOpus 11y agoThe hint is in the name. The "3L" consumes 3L/100km (under optimal conditions yada yada yada). That is 78.4mpg using US gallons or 94.2mpg using UK gallons.
- revelation 11y agoIt's crazy, with 84mpg this is just dead on arrival.
- goatforce5 11y agoI think it's a little sneaky that they only time they use to word 'car' on their materials is in a quote from a newspaper. Technically it's a motorcycle very similar to the Spyder - http://www.brp.ca/spyder/ http://www.brp.ca/spyder/ - and (as of 12 months ago) some states would require you to wear a helmet and/or take a motorcycle test for you to legally be able to drive this thing. https://eliomotors.wordpress.com/2014/05/16/lets-talk-about-laws-5-16-14/ https://eliomotors.wordpress.com/2014/05/16/lets-talk-about-... (I have no idea what progress they made on getting those laws changed in the past 12 months.)
- thrownaway2424 11y agoYep, pretty much every relevant state (representing nearly the entire US population) will require you to have a motorcycle license, and to wear a helmet. That's why Elio has been vaporware for nearly a decade and why they are trying to take their investor scam mainstream. They will never get to production.
- tbcj 11y agoWhat does "every relevant state" mean? The second and third most populous states don't require a helmet over 20, and the fifth doesn't require it at all.
- busterarm 11y agohttp://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/elio-motors-judicial-success-continues-with-american-association-of-motor-vehicles-administration-policy-recommendation-232389671.html http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/elio-motors-judicial... This plus the fact that 45+ states have already passed helmet exemptions for the Ello and other three-wheeled vehicles with non-removable roofs/windshields. http://www.technologytell.com/in-car-tech/5760/elio-motors-makes-progress-in-helmet-exemption-legislation/ http://www.technologytell.com/in-car-tech/5760/elio-motors-m...
- capex 11y agoAccording to their website, there's no helmet needed[0] in 45 states as of now. [0] http://www.eliomotors.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/helmetlaws.pdf http://www.eliomotors.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/helmetl...
- usaphp 11y agoI wonder how it will handle a crash test, for some reason I think it will be as unsafe as regular motorcycle. So you basically getting all the downsides of a motorcycle: safety, limited space, no passengers ,wearing a helmet (some states), without getting any upsides: beating traffic by skipping between lines (I know its illegal but most of the motorcycles do this), finding a parking easier, looking cool...The only thing it shares with a car is having a roof and easier driving. Imho it's better to get a $3K cheaper honda bike: http://powersports.honda.com/2015/rebel.aspx http://powersports.honda.com/2015/rebel.aspx
- obstinate 11y ago> So you basically getting all the downsides of a motorcycle Assuming your guess is correct, you capture the safety downside. But that is only a guess on your part. To me, it seems like a silly guess -- I'd expect that this will be less safe than a subcompact, but still a good deal safer than a motorcycle. There are still a few downsides you don't get. You get AC in this vehicle. You don't have to wear leathers because you can't fall. You have a sealed cabin, so road noise, while likely worse than a normal car, will be much better than a motorcycle. A trike is a lot more stable than a bike. > without getting any upsides Price? Fuel efficiency? Parking in such a small vehicle will be much easier than the smallest car, even if it's not quite as easy as a bike.
- usaphp 11y ago> Price? Fuel efficiency? Have you even read my comment? Motorcycles cost less than this thing by almost 3K, and have a better fuel efficiency - the motorcycle I linked above has an 84 MPG. > suffer the lack of AC or the fully exposed noise of the road That's what I said above, next time please read a comment before replying...
- obstinate 11y agoI read your comment before your edit, yes. You cite a $3k honda bike. This vehicle is $7k. A very cheap subcompact is $16k. So this vehicle captures about 75% of the price advantage of a bike compared to the cheapest car. In other words, it does capture most of the price upside, where you claimed it captured no upsides.
- toephu2 11y agoThis is not the car of the future. Still using gas? ICE (internal combustion engine)? 3 wheels? This has been tried before and did not work. This is a step backwards. Also who the heck names their company after themselves anymore? Talk about ego.
- barney54 11y agoWhy is the internal combustion engine a step backwards? Electric cars have some benefits, but they have had those benefits for more than 125 years. For more than a 100 years the problem has been cost and range and that hasn't been solved yet.
- Splendor 11y agoAs of right now 5,365 people have registered their (non-binding) interest in $21,462,675 worth of shares -- making the average reservation ~$4k.
- nodesocket 11y agoInteresting idea with the front/back seating, but honestly I can't image it actually drives well at all. The front with the pushed out wheels is super fugly as well.
- krisweston 11y agothe thing i dont like about this is the misleading way they put a picture of the earth on the car and say 'environmentally friendly!' - its not obviously, it still uses fossil fuels. shouldnt we have already got past those by now, seeing as we are all going to die if we dont ? :) yeah you can vote it down oil loving motherfucker, but you still going to die if we dont get rid of this oil shit.
- PhrosTT 11y agoI would be terrified of getting trapped in the backseat of that.
- HeyImAlex 11y ago> Today, there’s a new trailblazer working tirelessly to alter the course of history. His name is Paul Elio. He is gearing up to become the next Henry Ford and this is the public’s first opportunity to invest in Elio Motors at the ground level. You can be a part of the $52 billion U.S. personal transportation industry and own a part of the next new U.S. vehicle manufacturer. But you have to act now! That reads like an infomercial. Kind of makes you worried about crowd-investment...
- jasonmcalacanis 11y agoNot so fast.... these numbers are not confirmed in any way and can be gamed easily. I expand on it here. https://www.launchticker.com/story/automotive-co-eliomotors-crowdfunding-campaign-commitments-unsubstantiated-currently-displays-22m-in https://www.launchticker.com/story/automotive-co-eliomotors-... this is really bad for crowdfunding....
- smitherfield 11y agoTranslation - no institutional investors were stupid enough to give us [any more of] their money, but we think you are!