2 ms·
Bug bounties are sensible, but price-matching seems too easy to game. How can the company know a bid is serious, and not just fake to be matched? "Oh, sure, s
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Bug bounties are sensible, but price-matching seems too easy to game. How can the company know a bid is serious, and not just fake to be matched? "Oh, sure, so-and-so offered $200k for this bug."
(For that matter, while reputation is certainly a thing, what stops a security researcher from selling the same 0-day to several different buyers, and then selling it to the company to fix? Do the typical contracts to sell 0-days involve continued payment based on the amount of time the bug remains unfixed?)
- x0x0 11y agoI'd care a lot more if Adobe, et al, weren't repeatedly screwing up. A couple million dollar bounties and forcing them to pay to internalize their negative externalities will help create the proper internal focus on shipping secure software. Reputation doesn't show up as a line-item. And if a security dev resells, who cares? The company still got the 0-day and still gets it fixed asap. It's far better than our current situation where these can persist for years.
- BatFastard 11y agoHow about an escrow contract using a third party and bitcoin? You could call it silk road 3 Its really not that hard to be taken for a ride if you have the resource adobe does.
- ipsin 11y agoIf you know a company is legally obligated to pay up to $x, and that they have $x, you can offer to pay $x/1.1 in collusion/partnership with the bug-seller, for a share of the proceeds. You can outlaw the collusion, but setting up this kind of mechanic seems like a bad idea.
- toyg 11y ago> what stops a security researcher from selling the same 0-day to several different buyers, and then selling it to the company to fix? People willing to pay 5 or 6-digit sums for a zero-day are likely... not nice. One wouldn't double-cross them willy-nilly. Multiple-sale to multiple third-parties scenarios are likely happening every day, but selling to developers could be considered an act of sabotage against all buyers, so there is no incentive really.