4 ms·
I think this article has been posted three times with no comments so I thought I'd start one. It seems over cynical to me in that it passes over various succes
by tim333 11y ago
I think this article has been posted three times with no comments so I thought I'd start one.
It seems over cynical to me in that it passes over various successful models. LendingClub is doing well and has done over $5bn in loans. Transferwise seems to be going well and has done over $3bn of foreign transfers. Stripe is doing well. All are providing better service or value in fields that were poorly served and don't really fit with the articles views and categories.
- jackgavigan 11y agoI don't know a huge amount of LendingClub but I'll be very interested to see how well Stripe and Transferwise do in the long term. Both are spending a lot of money on expansion/marketing, and both operate in very competitive sectors.
- tim333 11y agoYeah, I'll be interested too. Stipe and Transferwise's sectors may be competitive now with other startups but they were kind of awful before they started. I'll also be interested to see how Tom Blomfield, formerly of GoCardless gets along with making a better current account. I went to a talk by him and it seems promising. http://www.techworld.com/mobile/mondo-ceo-tom-blomfield-explains-how-build-next-generation-digital-bank-3618866/ http://www.techworld.com/mobile/mondo-ceo-tom-blomfield-expl... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9638345 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9638345
- joosters 11y agoTo be fair, it is labelled a Cynic's Guide for a reason... I agree that LendingClub (and others, like Funding Circle) would be separate model from the ones listed in the article. Passing risk onto others and being paid a commission for the job of finding buyers & sellers. It's a little like his business model #4 but setting up a new exchange rather than using an existing one. That said, these 'alternative investment' style companies haven't yet been tested. What will happen when the next downturn arrives, and lenders get hit with massive losses?
- tim333 11y agoI guess you could argue Transferwise and Stripe fit in "model #7. Getting your act together with respect to an industry standard where the industry has conspicuously failed to do so" which he's positive about.
- notahacker 11y agoMy guess is that for many of the equity platforms, it won't take until the next downturn... Being a shovel seller in a gold rush is profitable enough whilst it lasts; the bigger worry is that it's not unheard of for UK regulators to decide that retail customers deserve compensation for financial products which were inadequately explained and a really bad deal, and put the vendor on the hook for it. I can almost imagine the next wave of robocalls from claims consultancies...
- joosters 11y agoYeah, there's a load of these p2p lending companies in the UK, some of them even describing themselves as 'savings' schemes rather than as speculative investment. That kind of language is asking for trouble. The business model even has remarkable similarities to some of the fundamental problems that aggravated the last mortgage collapse: the people who are credit rating these investments (i.e. the companies like Lending Club, Funding Circle, Zopa, RateSetter, Saving Stream and so on) are not the people taking the risk. So there's a great chance that the credit ratings will turn out not to be robust enough. IMO these companies should be forced to invest some of their own money in each of their lending offerings.
- jackgavigan 11y ago> Passing risk onto others and being paid a commission for the job of finding buyers & sellers. That's basically what investment banks do (and people are pretty cynical about it).
- joosters 11y agoTheir occasional massive losses would hint that they don't always do a good job of passing on the risk.
- x0x0 11y agoDid you read the article? Transferwise is explicitly listed as a successful model. Stripe probably falls under #7 -- efficiently implementing industry standards.
- brudgers 11y agoPlease consider editing your post to improve HN. From the HN Guidelines [see link at bottom of page]: Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."
- tim333 11y agoAh - missed that.
- notahacker 11y agoEven I think the article is a bit cynical, but in fairness #6 does specifically reference TransferWise as an example of the most successful business model: undercutting bank charges on price (and specialist providers on service) It's also written from a London Fintech scene perspective, so the success of Stripe and LendingClub isn't that relevant. In the latter case, the UK p2p funding market is more characterised by less-established companies with more speculative investment opportunities and a lot less regulation to protect the retail investor (and more schemes for the taxpayer to ultimately underwrite some of the losses), so I'm actually surprised the author didn't go after the crowdfunding industry. I think a "Business Model #9: saving on due diligence costs by selling the investment opportunities to people who don't know about adverse selection" would fit in nicely with his narrative.