13 ms·
Two more Flash 0-days emerge in Hacking Team leak
- a3n 11y agoHacking Team developed digital smallpox, and failed to safeguard it. Thanks.
- tptacek 11y agoI'm as grossed out by HT as the next message board nerd, but they didn't develop these bugs; modern industrial software development did. All HT did was weaponize them. These guys aren't the sharpest tools in the shed, so I think you can safely assume other people weaponized these, or worse bugs, as well.
- a3n 11y agoOK, point taken. But they had them in the lab, did not safeguard them properly (by demonstration), and deserve a shit ton of blame and scorn.
- EthanHeilman 11y agoHT purchased these vulnerabilities with an understanding that they would not be made public and patched. Then they failed to safeguard them. Clearly these O-days, and conceivably all computer vulnerabilities, are not close to being as bad as smallpox, but what ethical obligations do actors (companies, governments, hackers, researchers) have to protect vulnerabilities which they plan to not protect the public again? Say you discover a very powerful attack on AES which allows you under many circumstances to recover the key: 1. do you have an ethical obligation to warn affected parties? 2. If you don't and instead secretly sell this decryption capability to governments and/or private actors, do you have an obligation to ensure that this capability isn't used illegally or unethically? 3. What due diligence is required to protect a vulnerability of this scale?
- x0x0 11y agoWhy don't you 100% blame the people at fault: Adobe / the original developers. First, they were incompetent enough to not correctly develop their software. Second, non-assholes would have a standing price-match policy for bugs. Adobe should give you 110% of the highest bid you get for any 0-day. They could have fixed these a long time ago if they'd paid the discoverer $45k (or $150k -- times three for exclusivity.) These companies are effectively outsourcing security testing and remediation of their software, then whinging that independent developers don't work for free.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoBug bounties are sensible, but price-matching seems too easy to game. How can the company know a bid is serious, and not just fake to be matched? "Oh, sure, so-and-so offered $200k for this bug." (For that matter, while reputation is certainly a thing, what stops a security researcher from selling the same 0-day to several different buyers, and then selling it to the company to fix? Do the typical contracts to sell 0-days involve continued payment based on the amount of time the bug remains unfixed?)
- x0x0 11y agoI'd care a lot more if Adobe, et al, weren't repeatedly screwing up. A couple million dollar bounties and forcing them to pay to internalize their negative externalities will help create the proper internal focus on shipping secure software. Reputation doesn't show up as a line-item. And if a security dev resells, who cares? The company still got the 0-day and still gets it fixed asap. It's far better than our current situation where these can persist for years.
- BatFastard 11y agoHow about an escrow contract using a third party and bitcoin? You could call it silk road 3 Its really not that hard to be taken for a ride if you have the resource adobe does.
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 11y agoAnd this is just one non-governmental setup's arsenal.
- vtsrh 11y agoThe good part is that this removes the same vulnerability for everyone.
- ceejayoz 11y agoMy point, though, is that if a random Italian consultancy can amass multiple Flash 0-days, the folks at the NSA with the $10+ billion budget probably have an essentially endless supply of them (not to mention exploits for other software) at the ready.
- bohm 11y agoguess it's time to disable flash for a few weeks...
- ghshephard 11y agoA significant portion of the web using community (including myself) stopped using flash 6-12 months ago, when all the zero-days became a monthly occurrence. The plugin is no longer strategic for adobe, they've stopped any forward-looking development on it, and are now in the mode of whack-a-mole reactive security patching. I have not once every missed having flash on my system. It's not just the case that the web is useable, it's that, with the single exception of the BBC, it doesn't seem to use it anywhere I visit.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- joosters 11y agoThe BBC site will use non-flash videos if you browse it on an iPad, but they don't seem smart enough to serve these to you if you use a desktop browser with flash disabled. Presumably they could implement a non-flash fallback for users but unfortunately they just haven't bothered. I tried to cheat by modifying my User-Agent to pretend to be an iPad but had no luck...
- cormullion 11y agoI was going to agree with you, but I've just double-checked, and you CAN access video content on the BBC sites on a desktop (MacOS X Safari) by setting your User-Agent to iPad. However, it's important that you've removed Flash completely from your system (using Flash Uninstaller), rather than just disable Flash (hoping to use Click-To-Flash). For some reason, they detect Flash by some kind of file-path-detection code...
- joosters 11y agoThat's irritating! I'll have to take a closer look at what they are doing, as I'd like to keep flash around on a click-to-run basis. I'm surprised that websites can do any kind of file path detection on a client...
- dhimes 11y agoSerious question: why are people still using Flash? I'm surprised by the number of websites that use it.
- archgoon 11y agoA lot of advertising networks use it to deliver advertisements. Whether it is simple inertia at this point, or because the networks can get a better fingerprint using flash, I don't know. Also, it used to be the case that Flash had better DRM controls on it, but I'm pretty sure that reason is no longer the case since Encrypted Media Extensions got rolled out. However, that doesn't explain why Facebook's on-site video player uses Flash.
- shimfish 11y agoFacebook appears to have moved to an html player in the last few days.
- cpeterso 11y agoFacebook currently only supports HTML5 video for Windows 7+.
- hobarrera 11y agoNot for everyone, apparently. I'm still being prompted to install a plugin. Not only that, but images flagged as "gif" also prompt me to install flash (amazing how oddly these new features get implemented!).
- bydo 11y agoWhich is what makes these exploits so insidious: sneak an infected advertisement onto one network, even briefly, and you're now targeting who knows how many Internet users visiting legitimate, trusted websites. Honestly, one of the biggest reasons to run an ad blocker is the significantly reduced attack surface.
- ninkendo 11y agoThe advertising networks being the last to use it is something that will make Flash's implosion very quick and sudden, IMO. If uninstalling flash only causes you to miss out on ads, it makes uninstalling flash that much more attractive. Which makes the advertisers want to get off flash that much sooner. It needs probably just one or two more use cases to disappear (Facebook video is one of them), and its final death will be quite quick.
- therealmarv 11y agoIs there any Flash security bug recently which makes it outside the Chrome sandbox?
- steveax 11y agoYep, the one that became public 5 days ago [1] [1]: https://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/07/adobe-to-patch-hacking-teams-flash-zero-day/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/07/adobe-to-patch-hacking-t...
- bitmapbrother 11y agoOnly when used in tandem with a Windows exploit: "A spokesperson for Google confirmed that attackers could evade the Chrome sandbox by using the Flash exploit in tandem with another Windows vulnerability that appears to be unpatched at the moment."
- TD-Linux 11y agoThe Chrome sandbox isn't as strong as you might think. Flash needs access to a ton of stuff to work: - Camera / Microphone - Filesystem - GPU So there's plenty you can do without escaping the sandbox.
- sobkas 11y agoI would like to hear what Adobe have to say about their streak of serious security problems. Not only that, but they should face some consequences for that neglect. At least be forced to publish a working spec for Flash.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoIf they say much of anything, they will probably just reiterate that they take security very seriously.
- elorant 11y agoTheir clientele isn’t security wary people. Plus they don’t have any serious competition in most of their products so it can’t hurt them either way. So they’ll probably issue a generic statement and move on with their lives. As for consequences, the best thing most of us could do is disable Flash from the browser. I’ve done it since YouTube defaulted to HTML5 video and never looked back since.
- dguido 11y agoYou think that any other software you use is any better? Flash gets it rough because it's widely used and independent of the browser (for the most part). If you're running an update to date flash, that means you're probably running it in a sandbox and probably have silent auto updates turned on. That's good enough for most people. If you're the kind of person that's going to get specifically targeted, then you should not only reconsider running flash on your computer, but any other program written in an unsafe language. Or, you know, segregate your data.
- al2o3cr 11y ago"You think that any other software you use is any better?" I certainly HOPE most software I use can do better than this: http://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-53/product_id-6761/Adobe-Flash-Player.html http://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-53/pr... To be certain, Flash gets a lot of attention because of its install base - but it's been a never-ending FOUNTAIN of RCE bugs for much of the last decade.
- mahouse 11y agoWhat? I mean, how is this news?
- sobkas 11y agoWhat is news?
- mahouse 11y agoIsn't the record of infinite vulnerabilities in Flash widely known by everybody?
- sobkas 11y agoSo if it is so widely known, why no action was taken by anyone to stop them from undermining Internets security? Also not everyone knows how bad Flash is for their security, only few geeks care about reading cve-s. So until it goes to mainstream media not enough people will care.
- anarazel 11y agoApple dropped it and it was a large, if not the largest, reason for work on sandboxing plugins.
- chippy 11y agoum, no?
- mahouse 11y agohttp://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-53/product_id-6761/Adobe-Flash-Player.html http://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-53/pr...
- bitmapbrother 11y agoIE: 491 code exploit vulnerabilities Flash: 382 code exploit vulnerabilities. Looks like Flash has a way to go.
- curiousjorge 11y agodoes Chrome and Firefox automatically update the Flash? I can't turn it off because...well lot of video sites made for men that are not Youtube or Twitch but more popular than Vimeo ever will be, requires flash.
- DavideNL 11y agoGoogle Chrome - yes, it has Flash built-in. Firefox - "no", it doesn't have Flash built-in but uses Flash installed in the operating system. However, Flash installed separately for example in Windows/OS X also updates itself. However, you are screwed either way: always running the latest Flash player version which is known to be constantly full of security bugs, just like in the past 3 years... :)
- leni536 11y agoUse youtube-dl, or mpv with youtube-dl. It can fetch videos from many adult sites without using flash.
- chinathrow 11y agohttps://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/619876135623618560 https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/619876135623618560
- stevenh 11y agoMy Macbook kernel panics and force-reboots itself because of a bug in some newer Firefox browser feature(s) which are used by a JS-based GBA emulator which was trending on HN yesterday. I can consistently duplicate the kernel panic by resizing the browser window while the emulator is running. I've never in my life experienced such a catastrophic bug from a Flash demo. At worst, such a devastating bug has a decent chance of harboring its own RCE which has yet to be discovered or disclosed; at best, it's one of the most extreme local DOS attacks that a webpage could possibly launch against a client. Just because it's much more trendy to bash Adobe than it is to bash Firefox doesn't mean that Firefox's problems are nonexistent. Firefox RCE found on January 20, 2015: https://community.rapid7.com/community/metasploit/blog/2015/03/23/r7-2015-04-disclosure-mozilla-firefox-proxy-prototype-rce-cve-2014-8636 https://community.rapid7.com/community/metasploit/blog/2015/... Firefox RCE found on February 25, 2015: https://msisac.cisecurity.org/advisories/2015/2015-018.cfm https://msisac.cisecurity.org/advisories/2015/2015-018.cfm Firefox RCE found on March 1, 2015: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/security/advisories/mfsa2015-39/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/security/advisories/mfsa2015-3... Firefox RCE found on April 22, 2015: https://msisac.cisecurity.org/advisories/2015/2015-046.cfm https://msisac.cisecurity.org/advisories/2015/2015-046.cfm etc. Pot calling the kettle black.
- __david__ 11y agoI you are panicking the kernel, that is a kernel bug, not a JS/Firefox bug.
- Animats 11y agoFlash is decades old, not that big, and still has use-after-free vulnerabilities? Tools for catching those have been widely available for years. That makes one suspect those vulnerabilities aren't there by accident. We need public disclosure of the code check-in that created the bug, with names. People need to be fired for this.
- ceejayoz 11y agoFlash is big - video, audio, animation, browser hooks, filesystem access, etc. - and while Flash has been around for decades the code in the current iteration mostly hasn't been.
- wmt 11y agoWork on a massive decades old software project and get ready to have your eyes opened. All the automated static and dynamic software analyzers catch only the easiest flaws, but can catch the more serious ones only if you're skilled and lucky. Firing people for software bugs is the stupidest thing I've heard in a while. Everyone writes horrific software flaws. Everyone. The best of the best programmers just write less of them. Firing people for bugs is a job perk that will only motivate any good developers to find a less stupid employer as soon as possible.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoAll the automated static and dynamic software analyzers catch only the easiest flaws In a 64-bit environment, at least for development purposes, why can't every single malloc() cause an allocation from new memory page(s)? Then free() removes the page(s) from accessible virtual memory. Too much overhead for production, but it would sure catch a lot of use-after-free bugs during development. Is nobody doing something like that, or is that part of what you consider "the easiest flaws"?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 101914 11y agoFor me there are generally 3 steps to the process of watching a youtube video. 1. Get the video id. Retrieve HTML containing youtube /watch?v= urls or other urls that contain the video id. Extract the urls from the HTML or other markup garbage. 2. Retrieve the video. Feed the /watch?v= url to a script that does some "find and replace" on the absurdly long googlevideo urls. Below I have given an example of such a script. Complaints welcome. It takes a /watch?v= url on stdin and retrieves the video in the format specified on the command line. 3. Play the video. ffmpeg libraries, mplayer, etc. Whatever it is Flash does in the process of watching youtube videos (I am quite sure it is not step 3), I do not need it. Thus even if by not using Flash or a complex "modern" web browser to watch youtube videos somehow were to reduce my exposure to vulnerabilities that routinely occur in such software, I would not care. Because the reason I do not use Flash is.... because I do not need it. # proof of concept: video retrieval # requirements: # sh, sed, tr, openssl, ftp # Adobe Flash not required # HTML5 not required # Python not required # Awk not required # web browser not required curl=ftp file=1.mp4 # default outfile url=www.youtube.com # example # itag #s are on the wikipedia page for youtube f061(){ sed ' s,%3D,=,g; s,%3A,:,g; s,%2F,/,g; s,%3F,?,g; s/ //g; ' } f060(){ sed -e ' s/&itag=5//;t1 s/&itag=1[78]//;t1 s/&itag=22//;t1 s/&itag=3[4-8]//;t1 s/&itag=4[3-6]//;t1 s/&itag=1[346][0-9]//;t1 ' -e :1 } f062(){ sed ' s,http,\ &,g' } f063(){ sed ' /%3A%2F/!d; /videoplayback/!d' } f064(){ sed ' s,%26,\ ,g; s,&,\ ,g; ' } f065(){ sed 's/&https/\ \ https/g;' } f066(){ sed 's/\\u0026.*//' } f067(){ sed '/itag='"${1-.}"'/!d;' } f068(){ sed 's/%25/%/g' } f069(){ tr '\012' '&' } f070(){ sed 's/&$//'; echo } f071(){ local a061 a062 a063; while read a; do case $a in https://*)a061=${a#https://*/} ;; http://*)a061=${a#http://*/} ;; *)a061=${a#*/} ;; esac; a062=${a#*://}; a063=${a062%%/*}; printf "%b" "${1-GET} /${a061} HTTP/1.0\r\n" printf "Host: ${a063}\r\n"; printf "User-Agent: GoogleAnalytics 1.5.1\r\n"; printf "Connection: Close\r\n"; printf "\r\n"; done; } f072(){ openssl s_client -ign_eof -connect $1:${2-443} -verify 9 } case $# in [12]) { f071 \ |f072 $url \ |f062 \ |f063 \ |f061 \ |f060 \ |f064 \ |f068 \ |f069 \ |f070 } \ |f061 \ |f065 \ |f066 \ |f067 $1 \ |{ read a; exec $curl -4o ${2-$file} $a ; } ;; *) exec echo \ "usage: $0 itagno [outfile] outfile: $file" esac
- hobarrera 11y ago0-day exploits? I though that flash had been discontinued years ago. The last release I've found is 11.2, which seems to be years old and the last ever.
- Buge 11y agohttp://www.adobe.com/software/flash/about/ http://www.adobe.com/software/flash/about/
- hobarrera 11y agoHuh, I hadn't researched this before, but it looks like flash for Linux has been frozen for years, while the windows and OS X releases keep getting updates. So I guess Linux users are immute to this new zero-day?
- thrownaway2424 11y agoWhat are the people doing now who formerly developed Flash? Are they all diesel mechanics and baristas or what? I wouldn't even considering calling back a candidate why had Macromedia on their work history.
- scrollaway 11y ago> I wouldn't even considering calling back a candidate why had Macromedia on their work history. And I wouldn't even sort of consider hiring or even working with anyone that thinks work experience in a language makes them a liability.
- someguy1233 11y agoImportant PSA for Skype Users: Open up "Internet Options" (yes, the ones in internet explorer), security tab, and add https://apps.skype.com https://apps.skype.com to the "Restricted Sites" list. Skype will still work fine, however there will be no advertisements. This is important because Microsoft seems to use a lot of Flash advertisements without checking them (I've had plenty of "MICROSOFT VERIFIED DRIVER FIXING" ads come up inside of Skype, so I'm sure some zero day could slip though their ad system)
- aptwebapps 11y agoSkype on Windows has ads? Is that a recent thing? The Mac version doesn't, or not yet, anyway.
- chm 11y agoIf you want to do this on a Mac you can use software such as Little Snitch. Create a rule prohibiting Skype to connect to apps.skype.com.
- cooguy43 11y agoHacking really messes up our use of internet. I have italian practice on skype at http://preply.com/en/italian-by-skype http://preply.com/en/italian-by-skype and my teacher warns me about the sites that I visit.