2 ms·
Can we remove the subsidies on all forms of energy generation and let the market work it out? I suppose, at least, now the 'solar is cheaper than coal even wit
by TheSpiceIsLife 11y ago
Can we remove the subsidies on all forms of energy generation and let the market work it out?
I suppose, at least, now the 'solar is cheaper than coal even without subsidies' crowd can have an opportunity to see if the theory plays out in practice.
Edit to add: also, CEFC could be considered a wealth-transfer mechanism to the already wealthy property owning class (I get that many 'home owners' have large debts, but humour me here). As someone who chooses to rent I am excluded from roof-top solar subsidies. I generally disagree with this discrimination, but don't have a comprehensive alternative off the top of my head.
Solar shouldn't need subsidies and the energy retailers shouldn't be forced to buy roof-top solar at non-market rates. Governments probably shouldn't try to pick winners, at least not Australian governments, they're notoriously bad at it.
- d_t_w 11y agoOnly if you also calculate and charge a price on carbon emissions, and the current Australian government stopped that scheme last year.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoI don't know why you down-voted my comment. I've up voted everything you've contributed here. I was asking a question, it wasn't intended to be rhetorical, and your response is valid and I agree with it.
- d_t_w 11y agoI didn't down vote your comment, the timing was coincidental. I responded to it because I think a removal of all subsidies alongside correctly pricing the consequences of consumption is a valid end-goal. Personally I'd continue to subsidise renewables because I approve of them but I agree politicians are generally bad at picking winners.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoMy apologies for the assumption.
- anon1385 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality
- ams6110 11y agoExternalities can be negative or positive. I often see commenters bring up the negative externalities of coal but what about the positives: abundant, cheap, reliable electrical supply would have to be one. Employment in mining, processing, and transport of coal is another. A market for trains, trucks, mining equipment and supplies, etc. is another.
- shoo 11y agoA market operates in the context of some rules / regulation. If the rules of the market don't penalise you from doing things that have negative side-effects for everyone, such as polluting the atmosphere, then you can still make a lot of money by doing stupid things, to the point that more expensive less-stupid things cannot compete. > A comprehensive history of great business fortunes would show a disconcertingly large number that were made [where...] the enterpriser devised a silent way to commonize costs while continuing to privatize the profits. -- Garrett Hardin