12 ms·
All analogies break down eventually, but in this case I think you're jumping the gun. Do you have any idea how many clubs open and fail? Anyone can get a loan
by dasil003 17y ago
All analogies break down eventually, but in this case I think you're jumping the gun. Do you have any idea how many clubs open and fail? Anyone can get a loan and open a club. Making it successful is a whole nother ball of wax.
- anonjon 17y agoWell I'm sure a lot of clubs open and fail. But one has to assume that if you are opening a club, you have already been successful somewhere else. There is a much greater portrayal of starving musicians than there are starving club owners. It clearly follows that if you were not elsewise successful, and able to buy a club, your cousin Vinny has gifted this club to you in an offer that you simply could not pass up. Failing as a club owner almost directly implies that you failed in a secondary, non-career pursuit. The only way you can really starve in that situation is if you are a complete moron and actually invested your own money. Millions of guitarists, however, go hungry in the streets every day. Besides if you've taken out a loan to get the club, are you really a club owner? It seems like you are a proprietor most. Besides, the point of analogies is that they be based on easily falsifiable things that /seem to be/ true. An analogy is a metaphor. You know, literature fluff. This comparison doesn't /seem/ to be true, whether it is or not.
- dasil003 17y agoI understood the point of the article to be what it takes to be a successful club owner vs a successful guitarist and in that regard I think it worked even if the analogy is very rough around the edges.