3 ms·
It was lead in paint and gas that caused a rise in violent crime. It wasn't prisons that stopped that. The Drug War and school-to-prison pipleline are real, to
by Zigurd 11y ago
It was lead in paint and gas that caused a rise in violent crime. It wasn't prisons that stopped that.
The Drug War and school-to-prison pipleline are real, too. We farm black people to keep no-neck white men in "good jobs at good wages." If anything, the Drug War is preventing a further drop in crime as lead gets flushed out of the environment.
- rayiner 11y agoEverybody has their theory of why crime increased in the 70's and started coming down after the 90's. People tend to adopt the theory that fits their worldview. I'm partial to the lead theory myself because I'm a rabid environmentalists. Urbanists blame suburbanization and white flight. Civil libertarians blame the drug war. There is no conclusive proof or even extensive evidence in favor of any of those theories. But I think the drug war theory is one of the less compelling explanations given the evidence we have.
- Zigurd 11y agoThere have been meta-analyses of lead http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jan/07/violent-crime-lead-poisoning-british-export http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jan/07/violent... They are pretty compelling. Lead wasn't just about crime. Tetraethyl lead was almost a global disaster that might have cost humanity dearly in some very general ways. The hypothesis is very strong, too. Refinery workers went violently insane. There was no question what the effect would be if there was enough cause to cause it.
- tptacek 11y agoSeems like everyone can be right about this. Lead. Intoxicated dissipation, a stagnant pool that has bred crime for millenia. Poverty. White flight. Restrictions on family planning. And all these things feed on each other. Stop and ask yourself: is there anyone who regularly writes on HN who thinks the drug war is a good thing? If you took a poll of HN commenters, full legalization would come out, where, 98%? Clearly, when we discuss prison and the drug war, we're all talking about something more subtle than whether we should imprison people for doing drugs.
- Zigurd 11y agoIt's more important to find agreement on what it isn't: It isn't the black race, and the cure isn't harsh discipline and criminalization of behavior in schools, and stop-and-frisk laws that target mostly black people. Unfortunately, while the libertarians might make HN look wise about the Drug War, there are way too many people, even on HN, who are happy with, and who have various justifications for, prisons filled with black and latino prisoners.