3 ms·
The real question is if we are changing a very productive system for a not soo good one. Octopuses growth much quicker than strawerries, and are also more expen
by pvaldes 11y ago
The real question is if we are changing a very productive system for a not soo good one. Octopuses growth much quicker than strawerries, and are also more expensive. Any aquaculture system in the same area will provide much more human food and better revenues (you are using a 3d volume for production instead a 2d surface).
Marine soil is not apt to cultivate, so you need to put terrestrial soil underwater (or hydroponics), and this is not cheap. There is also a real possibility of contamination of beaches with manure after a storm.
- geon 11y ago> There is also a real possibility of contamination of beaches with manure after a storm. One of the few advantages of underwater agriculture would be the absence of storms. Only a few meters down, you won't notice a storm at all.
- pvaldes 11y agoTrust me, you will notice it. River deltas are made of sediments and carry heavy stones and trunks for several km after a strong storm. Even the slightest flood will nuke your small underwater plastic balloon and carry the remains many miles offshore. If you want to have any opportunity with underwater "put-some-activity-here" you absolutely need to have a way to put all your stuff safely out of the sea before a gale or a strong storm. I will not recommend to invest a single cent in underwater permanent activity that do not have a solid plan B for bad weather days.
- Trombone12 11y agoI think they've implemented the plan "don't put it in a river outlet"
- imaginenore 11y agoOctopuses are some of the smartest animals. Not a vegetarian, but I can't eat one. It's like eating a monkey.
- pvaldes 11y agoWell, if this make you feel better, only dumbest octopuses will be caught and fried. They have short lives in any case.
- Shivetya 11y agoand they don't look good on short cake. My concerns with this are, how do they deliver power and what its requirements compared to a surface enclosed farm? Do they get sufficient light at that depth to not need artificial lighting? While it is nice to see the sea life adapting that is merely a distraction from real issue of cost and are there negative affects on sea life?
- pvaldes 11y agoI guess that strawberries are specifically choosen by the relatively low light requirements. I'm very sceptic about other hidden costs like hand polinization vs minute of bottle diving, or how they had solved damages of amphibious marine snails in the fruits.
- bagosm 11y agoYou compare apples to oranges. Octopi would need food to live and that food is a huge cost in resources. Octopi consume a feed that could have been human to begin with. Plants need only water and reused plant material or any other natural fertilizer.
- pvaldes 11y agoNot, we are talking about space here. 1) First of all, this space is of public nature. We could earn a lot of money for example, if we'll convert Central Park in our private artichoke's field but this will never occur. We could also dream about to privatize the mediterranean marine platform just for our own profit but this is against the current laws. If you can build a greenhouse underwater, everybody could also build a underwater hotel for instance. You can not raise a wall all around a nice beach and then ask money to people that wish to use this beach. Is public space. 2) Is economically crazy. The permits to grant a new marine farm to culture fishes are scarcer than plutonium in Mediterranean just right now and one of the reasons is the contamination. The idea of culturing cheaper products like strawberries in the same place is like to bury a diamond mine under a parking. Those strawberry fields are currently destined to a very profitable culture of marine plants (Agar based companies), fishes, shellfishes, and also turism. Even if you put enough manure to having a good annual harvest of strawberries two months each year (and you are really lucky that fishermen just accept go away and don't destroy your greenway with their trawl nets) you are just losing money. 3) Is not scalable. What they are doing would be clearly illegal for any of us. If the goal is "to feed the planet", to substitute the essential proteins provided by fishes and shellfishes by a harvest of lattices or strawberries is plain wrong. Poor people need (imperatively) more proteins in their diet, not more sugar.
- pvaldes 11y ago> ...don't destroy your 'greenway' with their trawl nets (ouch, is 'greenhouse' of course).