4 ms·
Consider the neutral statements that were deleted: “It became clear that the board and I had a different view on the ability of Reddit to grow this year,” Ms.
by leereeves 11y ago
Consider the neutral statements that were deleted:
“It became clear that the board and I had a different view on the ability of Reddit to grow this year,” Ms. Pao said in an interview. “Because of that, it made sense to bring someone in that shared the same view.”
Sam Altman, a member of Reddit’s board, said he personally appreciated Ms. Pao’s efforts during her two years working at the start-up. “Ellen has done a phenomenal job, especially in the last few months,” he said.
Also consider what the article left out, like the complaints of IAmA mods about the way Victoria was terminated; the requirement that all employees move to San Francisco; the ban on salary negotiations; the community manager who said he was fired for being too sick to work; the complaints from mods about poor support from the admins.
Some opinion pieces explicitly state an opinion. This one conveys an opinion by cherry-picking facts and quotes.
- tptacek 11y ago* Contra your argument, the piece retains Pao's claim that she left because of differences on the direction of the company. * The Altman quote that was removed favors Pao's supporters. Removing it makes her plight less sympathetic. * Contra your argument, the petition not only remains in the final story, but has its own graf. * Contra your argument, the piece retains the concern about Victoria's firing. * The relocation of Reddit's employees was a Yishan Wong initiative, as was the salary negotiation policy. There is virtually no news story that you can't attack for "leaving out facts". You might not like this reported news story, but it is not an opinion piece.
- leereeves 11y agoYou're right about the petition. Mea culpa; it was just moved. What's your source re the salary negotiation policy? Numerous news stories said it was Pao's decision. The move to SF was often brought up again in discussions over the past couple weeks. Contra the misogyny argument, there's anger at reddit that pre-dates Pao. Regarding the Altman quote and Pao's statement that "it made sense to bring someone in that shared the same view", I can see your interpretation, though I disagree. Regarding Victoria's firing: yes, the NYT mentioned it, but without explaining why it angered the mods so much.
- tptacek 11y agoHere is the entire Victoria graf: Ms. Pao’s departure from Reddit was prompted after the online message board’s tight-knit community broke into upheaval when news broke that Victoria Taylor, a prominent and well-liked Reddit employee, had been suddenly dismissed from the company this month with no public explanation. In protest, Reddit users shut down hundreds of sections of the message board. This graf: * Establishes an objective cause of Pao's ouster --- the firing of Victoria Taylor --- that Pao's opponents widely agree is the reason she left. * Calls into question the reason for Taylor's firing. * Reports the subreddit strike, which was done precisely to get this sort of attention. At no point does the graf downplay the firing or somehow mitigate Pao's involvement in it. Which it easily could have, because Pao didn't fire Taylor, Ohanian did. I do not think you can win an argument that the Times tried to spin the Victoria Taylor issue out of the article.
- leereeves 11y ago> I do not think you can win an argument that the Times tried to spin the Victoria Taylor issue out of the article. That's not exactly what I said, and certainly nothing I meant to imply. Allow me to try again: The article ignored the complaints expressed by the moderators.
- tptacek 11y agoThe article also ignores the fact that Pao didn't fire Taylor, and that the issue of how AMAs were going to be moderated was in Ohanian's portfolio, not hers. That fact is more material to the article than the specifics of the moderator complaints about Taylor --- for instance, it speaks to the difficult situation Pao was in managing a team that included Reddit's charismatic founder and the chairman of the company, in an operational role. But it also isn't in the article.
- selimthegrim 11y agoSurely Pao must have signed off on the decision at some point?