3 ms·
As a mere reader and non-user of SO, does it matter if the question was closed? The answer's still there, googlable, and it still gets updated regularly, no?
by scrollaway 11y ago
As a mere reader and non-user of SO, does it matter if the question was closed? The answer's still there, googlable, and it still gets updated regularly, no?
- christianmann 11y agoIt suggests that this is not the ideal sort of question for the site, and that any future attempts at similar questions may be met with greater resistance. Additionally, if the relevant information ever changes, no new answers can be submitted.
- Retra 11y agoThere is a lot of linking to other SO answers, so if someone asks a question about new information, you can still refer to closed questions and expound on them. I'm not sure if that's the best way to do it, but it's an option.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoIf SO really feels these questions are unworthy, they should add a noindex tag to the result and give up the Google juice. Something tells me that's never going to happen, though.
- cardiffspaceman 11y agoI posted an answer to a question that had an accepted answer, and it gets upvotes once in a while. The accepted answer was correct at the time. My search for the answer later turned up the SO question and answer plus the new correct answer from the cmake site. So I posted my new information as a new answer. I think if a question is closed, that would mean no corrections or updates would be possible.
- DanBC 11y agoSO incentivises some stuff. You ask a question and you get points if other people upvote your question. You answer a question and you get points if someone upvotes your answer. You can't vote on closed questions or answers to closed questions. A question can't just be closed. There needs to be a reason to close it. "This question is a duplicate of this other question" is frequently used. Often the questions are similar but different enough to need a new question. You can't ask a broad question to capture all the variation - that'll get closed as too broad. You can't focus in on your exact problem -that'll get closed as too narrow. The gap in the middle is full of dupes. It's pretty demoralising to have people picking over your question and closing it for (seemingly bogus) reasons or asking for pointless clarification.
- codinghorror 11y agoIncorrect, you can vote on closed questions. You just can't add new answers.
- curiousjorge 11y agoI understand that SO is about building a knowledgebase but isn't it clear that a lot of people view SO as more of a Q&A + forum? When you close a question, it feels like censorship, which is frustrating because continued discussion and up to date answers are almost always expected. Anyhow, SO isn't the same site it was 5 years ago. It's actually pretty darn toxic for new userbase and seems to cater to the mods themselves.
- mistermann 11y ago> continued discussion and up to date answers are almost always expected That's another frustrating gap in SO: the absolute ignorance of the notion of time and change. Both questions and answers often have a significant timeliness attribute (ex: what are the best online resources for learning <x> as of Jan 2015), and SO has no support for this. To be fair it's a hard problem, but I'm not even aware if it has even been discussed. I'd like to think that the platform is now mature and tuned enough that they could start to introduce some major new functionality rather than just keeping the lights on.
- mcnamaratw 11y agoYeah. Ha, maybe the toxic culture is a sort of game-theory equilibrium that keeps out new mods.
- DanBC 11y agoAh, sorry. Thanks for the clarification.
- ivanhoe 11y agoIn programming (and many other fields) things change quickly, something that was a good idea 3-4 years ago may now be a really bad advice. Closed questions can't be updated with the improved answers, so IMHO they simply can't be trusted anymore