3 ms·
No. The widened circle of evolutionary concern that we display is due to a great deal of socialisation and enculturation. Most people, in most places throughout
by barry-cotter 11y ago
No. The widened circle of evolutionary concern that we display is due to a great deal of socialisation and enculturation. Most people, in most places throughout history have not treated members of the outgroup as having rights or worth.
There are some wonderful parts of The Better Angels of Our Nature, Steven Pinker, but one of my favourites was him taking the piss out of Richard Dawkins for thinking Saddam Hussein was uniquely and especially evil, worthy of individual study. Saddam's morality is vastly closer to the historical norm than that of educated elite Westerners.
Where psychopaths differ from non-psychopaths is not in how they treat the outgroup, but in how they treat the ingroup.
- charlieflowers 11y ago> Where psychopaths differ from non-psychopaths is not in how they treat the outgroup, but in how they treat the ingroup. That distinction makes sense. My real point was that many of the descriptions I've read of the symptoms or the definition of psychopathy do not make any such distinction (granted, many of these were in the press, not the most authoritative sources).
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI totally agree. In discussions on race and gender discrimination, I often argue that these are evidence of human nature's trend to (a) group together + support those similar to oneself; (b) compete with or mistreat those outside the group. It's a nice abstraction on top of all the forms I've seen of this that gets to the real issue. Now, the specific forms of it certainly develop their own mental baggage and reinforcements on top of this. Yet, without being a sociology/psych major, I think this is a normal thing that should be recognized and hit head on by any reformists. That it's a weakness in human nature must be understood before it can be beaten. Otherwise, strawmen and red herrings abound.