3 ms·
It doesn't actually benefit anyone to convince people that sex outside of marriage is bad unless it really is is bad. In fact, it's a huge hedonic loss for ever
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
It doesn't actually benefit anyone to convince people that sex outside of marriage is bad unless it really is is bad. In fact, it's a huge hedonic loss for everyone. It doesn't even help the political classes, because as rich high status men, they are prevented from having the extramarital sex which comes easily to them (or at least they must hide it). However, it's in the direct benefit of perverts and sex freaks to convince people that extramarital sex is harmless. One side has motives and vested interests to lie, the other really does not.
If your logic is valid but mine is not, please explain to me why.
- philwelch 17y agoYour argument is invalid because there are practically no scientists (social or otherwise) coming out against premarital sex in modern societies with adequate screening against STDs and responsible use of contraception. Honestly, sex outside of marriage probably was bad in the medieval society where the Roman Catholic Church pushed that doctrine on all of us. It wasn't until the invention of reliable birth control in the 20th century that it wasn't a bad idea, but religious doctrines tend not to keep up with the times as well (hence modern day Muslims and Jews eschewing entire categories of food because they couldn't be trusted to be healthy in ancient Israel). Interestingly enough, the RCC hasn't managed to buy off enough scientists to fabricate much evidence that condoms and the pill are a bum deal. I guess to some Catholics though, all the scientists who publish studies saying that the pill is 99% effective and condoms can stop the spread of HIV are secretly agents of godless secular humanism. While I'm sure some environmentalist devotions rise (sink?) to the level of unexamined religious belief, most of them push silly pseudoscientific hypotheses ("Gaia") which do not, in fact, actually get much scientific literature to support them.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoPhil, you didn't make an argument about scientists. You made a blanket statement about everyone, and singled out the political classes. It doesn't actually benefit anyone to convince people that anthropogenic climate change exists unless anthropogenic climate change actually exists. In fact, it's a huge pain in the ass for everyone...It doesn't even help the political classes... Incidentally, scientific communities have gotten behind theories with little evidence for political or religious purposes: Lysenkoism and various eugenic theories, for example.
- philwelch 17y agoThe topic under discussion is "social pressure on scientists to fabricate evidence towards some sort of ulterior motive". Perhaps I should have explicitly restated that, but I assumed the way our respective comments are threaded implied it well enough.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYour argument explicitly mentions "anyone" and "political classes"; in no way does it single out scientists. It's a very general argument which, based on context, I assumed you were specializing to scientists. If you wish to claim it is true for scientists, but not people in general, you'll need to explain what special features of scientists make the argument true for them. In any case, there is direct benefit to climate scientists to exaggerate the dangers/probabilities of climate change: it raises the importance of their field and by extension themselves. Exaggerated fears of global warming benefit climate scientists, just as exaggerated fears of the next great depression benefited Nouriel Roubini.
- philwelch 17y agoI was responding to the vague claim that statists, who have an interest in increasing the power of the federal government, are exerting influence on climate scientists to fraudulently manufacture a rationale for a presumably wide-ranging and invasive intervention in the economy. My argument is that it's very hard to identify any sufficiently powerful group with any identifiably vested interest in fraudulent climate science other than the petroleum, automotive, and energy industries.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoIt's very hard to identify any sufficiently powerful group with any identifiable profit motive for fraudulent sex research either. People sometimes push an agenda for irrational ideological reasons rather than simply profit. Incidentally, bad sex research was fairly common. Homosexuality used to be classified as a disease, for example.
- Retric 17y agoInfectious disease. When you base an initial argument on a false statement it becomes meaningless.