4 ms·
What? Clearly both should be banned, but banning one is much better than banning neither.
by mcphage 11y ago
What? Clearly both should be banned, but banning one is much better than banning neither.
- CamperBob2 11y agoNo, it isn't. Given that there was no blatantly illegal content involved, there are only two possible reasons for not treating these two subreddits the same. Either the admins are a) clueless nitwits who don't know what's going on with their own site, or b) sympathetic to one but not the other. Which do you believe is the correct explanation? Can you see any other possibilities?
- mcphage 11y agoIf you're in my house, I'm going to hold you to a much higher standard than "not blatantly illegal". If you resent Reddit doing the same, well, the Internet isn't lacking for dank underbellies.
- CamperBob2 11y agoSo I'm allowed to hold Klan meetings in your house, as long as I don't make fun of any overweight minorities? Because that's what the admins have basically said, by their actions.
- mcphage 11y ago> Because that's what the admins have basically said, by their actions. Nope, the Reddit admins just haven't closed those subreddits yet. But they will. They've closed the child porn subreddits, they've closed the revenge porn subreddits, they've closed the hate groups that bleed out into the larger internet. r/coontown will be closed, too. It hasn't yet, which is a shame, but if you read into that fact that the reddit admins approve of it, then be prepared to be disappointed in a few months when it gets closed, too.
- foiboitoi 11y agoFunny how you're getting downvoted for stating the obvious.
- CamperBob2 11y agoI probably sound more vested in the issue than I am. I probably also sound like I'm piling on with unhelpful feedback at a difficult time. I don't intend either -- I'm just a bit perplexed at why some forms of controversial, hate-oriented, and/or immature speech are considered OK on Reddit while others aren't.
- mcphage 11y agoThey're getting downvoted for stating that it would be better if r/fatpeoplehate was still active on Reddit.
- CamperBob2 11y agoYou do have an active imagination, I'll give you that much credit.
- danielweber 11y agoNo, because it leads to an incoherent policy. Reddit's original policy, for better or for worse, was "anything that isn't illegal." They had to add one or two things to that over the years but they stuck to that. Reddit's policy then became, unofficially, "trust us to get rid of the crap." That sounds fine, but it has problems: 1. it's not the original policy. HN has a "trust us" policy and it works great but it's always had that. HN has never been billed as "come say what you want." Changing the policy is a bait and switch to the old community. 2. It was never admitted to. While switching to the new policy, the official line was that the old policy was still in place. 3. It requires positive social capital. Remember Philip Greenspun's infamous article describing the VCs at ArsDigita as "a group of nursery school children who've stolen a Boeing 747 and are now flipping all the switches trying to get it to take off"[1]? That's what the reddit admin has been like for months, and it leads to negative social capital. Some guy was shadowbanned but didn't know it for years, patiently posting in subreddits all along. The CEO didn't use the company's only product. If you've ever experienced a dysfunctional internet community -- and who hasn't -- you recognize the patterns of decisions made in a hurry to stop whomever is immediately yelling at you and then trying to justify it with whatever they can cobble together afterwards, and that explanation will be completely unsuitable for the next crisis which will require yet another made up explanation. [1] http://waxy.org/random/arsdigita/ http://waxy.org/random/arsdigita/
- aiiane 11y agoLetting the perfect be the enemy of the good isn't great either.
- danielweber 11y agoThis isn't responsive to anything I said. It's a response to a different comment that says "they should only get rid of all toxic communities, not just some of them." Building a community requires trust from the community members, especially the community members who are volunteers donating their time to help the long-term health of it. If the people in charge consistently act like they don't know what the fuck they are doing the volunteers quickly feel put upon. The hardest part of managing a user community is dealing with all the users.
- venomsnake 11y agoWhy they should be banned? You know that you can just stay away.