3 ms·
I accidentally upvoted you, so I feel I have to weigh in here. I find you greatly oversimplify in order to prevent your own understanding of the greater issues
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I accidentally upvoted you, so I feel I have to weigh in here.
I find you greatly oversimplify in order to prevent your own understanding of the greater issues involved.
Let's assume for a moment that every American is totally dedicated to helping his fellow man as much as possible. Would that necessarily result in free public healthcare? It's a perfectly reasonable (yet unpopular view) to think that helping other people means doing the things that result in the greater, longer-term good, and that might mean make life miserable. Humanity that struggles is humanity that innovates, adapts, and evolves. Humanity that stagnates does not. There is a very good case to be made for inaction.
It's also quite ludicrous to think that, given the inclination to take some sort of direct action in my fellow man's affairs that _you_ get to define what the appropriate sort of action might be. Perhaps instead of a free doctor, I feel that a cash stipend might be best, where the recipient gets to choose how it is spent. Or, perhaps because I think poor people have poor spending habits, I choose to provide free shelter. To even start thinking along the lines that one solution would fit all problems is to engage in the most wide over-generalizations. And to think that you (or anybody else) gets to decide what this one solution would be and basically try to shame everybody else into accepting this one answer is a non-starter. Reasonable people are going to tell you to go jump in a lake.
Finally, it's completely disconnected to think that my actions have a direct result on other people's lives. People have a dignity and respect that is part of who they are, foibles and all. My writing a check doesn't make a person into a better one, doesn't necessarily improve their life, and might actually make their problems worse. People are who they are. Even when I'm committed to action, even when I've decided to take direct action, even when I think I know what the best action is, I take action because it is the right thing to do for me, not because I'm expecting some sort of miracle result from it.
Having said that, I think there is a strong moral case for some sort of catastrophic health insurance -- mainly because people cannot be allowed to forfeit their life savings because they had the misfortune to die from expensive diseases. However, I respect that others might choose to let each man fend for himself. This country was founded by people braving the wilds, not hanging out at the soup kitchen. As a species, in my opinion, the more comfortable we make our cave, the less likely we ever are to venture out of it (travel to the stars)
- abstractbill 17y agoThis argument could easily be extended to other services. Thus, we should not have fire or police services, because they make us too comfortable and might stop us from reaching for the stars. If you draw the line so that tax money does fund fire and police services, then why not medical? It's easily as big of a benefit to society, imho.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThis argument could easily be extended to other services If I thought this was some sort of generic argument for anarchy I wouldn't have used it. These questions are long settled: where private property rights intrude, some sort of collective protection of private property is required, whether military, police, fire, etc. The edges of these arguments -- where they do not apply -- are as important if not more important than the arguments themselves. There's a good reason the police department is not like the social services department. It's not all just sort of the same.
- abstractbill 17y agoThese questions are long settled Don't you find it even just a little curious that in every other developed nation, the questions have been settled in a different way? where private property rights intrude, some sort of collective protection of private property is required My body is the most important piece of property I own. If the government protects some of my property (e.g. my house, from a fire), why does it not protect the most important piece?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoDon't you find it even just a little odd that in every other developed nation, the questions have been settled in a different way? Gosh no, because I don't mix up discretionary spending with required spending. We spend lots on things we like to do, like sports stadiums, airports, etc. There's no reason we can't choose to spend some money on something like healthcare. I just wouldn't mix expenses like that up with expenses like the local vice squad. My body is the most important piece of property I own. If the government protects some of my property (e.g. my house, from a fire), why does it not protect the most important piece? Once again, these questions are long settled. Your body is indeed the most precious thing you own, and the government's obligation to protect your body ends in two places: at your skin (meaning the government really has no business telling you how to treat your body) and at your neighbor's property (meaning your right to live doesn't include stealing food from the neighbor's farm) Once again, that doesn't mean that we can't help hungry or ill people. Of course we can. It just means that it's not the same kind of necessary invasion of private property as, say, drafting your kid and sending him off to war because the nation is in danger.