2 ms·
> While blatant voting manipulation may be the status quo at a certain other startup-oriented link aggregator, it is never good because it breaks the integrity
by geofft 11y ago
> While blatant voting manipulation may be the status quo at a certain other startup-oriented link aggregator, it is never good because it breaks the integrity of the service.
Why does it break the integrity of the service? Sockpuppets, sure, but why does asking friends/acquaintances with established HN accounts (presumably the HN software can distinguish these cases) for upvotes work contrary to the goals?
Presumably if you have an account and you "vote well" -- that is, your upvotes are well-correlated with what other people upvote and don't downvote -- you know what people like to see. If a friend asked me to upvote their spam listicle, or a question they could just ask me and get an answer, or some politics story irrelevant to hackerdom, I'd say no. If I "manipulate" a friend's post, I'm making as much of an endorsement of the content as HN-appropriate as if I upvoted something I saw on the front page. (And if I abuse that, my upvotes should get disregarded.)
To be clear, I'm not advocating that bugging your friends for upvotes is a good system. I am advocating that posters asking people who care about HN for endorsement is explicitly desirable, and the software and community norms should be designed to reflect this, instead of the community norm deciding that vote manipulation is an acceptable means to an otherwise-technically-unsupported end.