2 ms·
> I think the problem is how easy it is to game HN, how effective it is to game HN, and how random and spurious it is if you don't game HN. I didn't discuss it
by minimaxir 11y ago
> I think the problem is how easy it is to game HN, how effective it is to game HN, and how random and spurious it is if you don't game HN.
I didn't discuss it in the original post, but HN has an anti-gaming mechanism: flagging.
Flagging is much more powerful than an upvote. If a completely terrible article/startup is posted and gamed so that it hits the Top 5, the attention will cause it to get more flags faster and die even faster. Thus, it's self correcting. This also addresses your "promoting a loophole" argument.
- austenallred 11y agoYou don't know if something has been gamed unless it's blatantly obvious or they're tweeting about it. So flagging doesn't solve that problem.
- tptacek 11y agoPlease don't use flags as downvotes, though. Flag things that are inappropriate for HN. Don't flag things to try to rebalance the front page.
- woah 11y agoWeren't you the one advocating flagging of surveillance-related news articles?
- tptacek 11y agoI don't flag "surveillance articles". I flag political articles, and blogspam retreads of things that have already generated 300-comment threads earlier in the day. I think HN is really bad at discussing surveillance issues, but I don't think that makes the articles --- which are mostly about technology --- inappropriate for HN.
- woah 11y agoThis only works for blatantly terrible articles. There is a lot of gaming of ok or mediocre startup announcements. I have personally seen it being done (and even participated!) to great effect. It's called bugging your friends for up votes.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> It's called bugging your friends for up votes. I always found such behaviour pathetic, but it increasingly becomes apparent to me that trying to be decent is a handicap and successful people are those willing to do anything, no matter how despicable.
- tptacek 11y ago"Bugging your friends for upvotes" is risky on modern HN.