6 ms·
Tell HN: If your HN submission doesn't get any upvotes, don't worry about it
I've recently been seeing many comments on Hacker News complaining that their submissions don't receive any points. As a result, they believe that vote manipulation techniques such as begging friends for votes on social media and using sockpuppet accounts to counteract this injustice are justifiable and that "everyone's doing it". While blatant voting manipulation may be the status quo at a certain other startup-oriented link aggregator, it is never good because it breaks the integrity of the service.
However, the lack of upvotes is just how link aggregators work.
The goal of many HN posters is to hit the front page. If you've received 10 points, you'll probably have hit the front page. However, depending on time of submission, you have a 10% to 20% chance of hitting 10 points: http://i.imgur.com/MdUvMB9.png
That's low, even if your blog post or startup is the Next Big Thing.
However, what's the typical behavior for HN submissions? Here's a chart of the median points for HN submissions at each timeslot: http://i.imgur.com/SN5BuAJ.png
The median is either 1 (no upvotes) or 2 (just 1 upvote), which reinforces how the typical behavior of HN really is.
Yes, it's possible for submissions to slip through the cracks. HN allows resubmission of links if they haven't had any discussion (as long as you don't delete-then-resubmit to obfuscate the fact that it's a report). If your submission doesn't get points, submit again later.
(Code and data for the two charts are available in this GitHub repository: https://github.com/minimaxir/hn-heatmaps)
- minimaxir 11y agoClickables: 10+ points chart: http://i.imgur.com/MdUvMB9.png http://i.imgur.com/MdUvMB9.png Median chart: http://i.imgur.com/SN5BuAJ.png http://i.imgur.com/SN5BuAJ.png GitHub Repository: https://github.com/minimaxir/hn-heatmaps https://github.com/minimaxir/hn-heatmaps
- aakilfernandes 11y agoHN really should allow resubmissions after a certain number of days. Its fine to have an imperfect algorithm, its rather frustrating to pretends its perfect.
- tptacek 11y agoIt does. Just put ?resubmitted=true (or any other junk) at the end of your URL. Wait a couple days before doing it. Don't resubmit if your original submission generated a thread, or hit the front page (you can resubmit if that happens later in the year).
- sarciszewski 11y agoI had no idea this was a thing. :O
- JoshTriplett 11y agoOr, more simply and without actually sending query parameters to the site, append an empty anchor '#'.
- tptacek 11y agoThe one reason I have not to just put empty anchors on pages is that people might write comments saying your story is a "dupe" if you don't make it obvious that was intentional. (But then, they may do that anyways).
- minimaxir 11y agoYou can append "?hn=1" to resubmit. It's not perfect and I wish it was more mechanical, though.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoQuery parameters don't require a value. A blank /?/* is perfectly enough.
- czinck 11y agoAlso, the way HN is designed the dupe-check only works on the last N posts (that are in memory), so if you wait a while you can resubmit without any of the tricks others have mentioned. You'll need to wait over a week, though (not sure the exact time).
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI've been noticing recently that submissions I post will go for hours without upvotes, and then at some point around the 7th hour or so they'll climb to the middle of the front page with around 15-20 upvotes. Is this manual intervention, or is HN testing out some new heuristic?
- weavie 11y agoI think when you submit something that has already been posted it will add a vote the existing submission. So probably you got there first and a load of people tried to submit 7 hours later.
- halviti 11y agoThis is just how things on the internet work. Think about it logically. Not every person is going to see every single new submission. It takes time for the submission, if it is any good, to gain momentum and rise to the level that more people will see it. The more people that see it, the more votes it will receive. Unless your submission is really popular or noteworthy for some reason, 8 hours seems fairly typical for an average submission.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoExcept from my observations, at such a timeframe most of them simply die from lack of visibility, or even if they do gain upvotes, they don't actually hit the front page (I think a time-based penalty?). I was thinking out loud because dang has been speaking of HN testing out a new feature to resurrect posts from hellbanned users (and because HN has been sending out emails asking people to repost stories), and assumed some other mechanism is also being tried out.
- dang 11y agoYou're referring to a few different experiments, but the one relevant to your question upthread is what I wrote about at [1], specifically "reviewing the story stream for high-quality submissions and occasionally lobbing one or two of them onto the bottom of the front page". How this currently works is that when we notice a substantive overlooked story, we add it to a pool. Every now and then software picks one from the pool and randomly places it near the bottom of the front page. It does that by reducing the time decay and/or adding a small number of points. If too much time has gone by for a small change to suffice, the software doesn't try, and instead we sometimes email an invitation to repost the story. This system would never add 15 points, nor place a story as high as the middle of the front page, so if that's what you saw it means the community noticed the post at the bottom and took it from there—which is the intent of doing this in the first place. We don't much care which stories get taken up this way vs. which don't. The idea is to do the minimum necessary to give high-quality stories a second chance and mollify the cruelty of /newest. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8790134 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8790134
- seiji 11y agoGreat points. Non-submitters seldom realize how often new content goes ignored around here. Unless you're one of the top 20 most recognized names here or unless you're writing about fad-of-the-week, submissions are mostly ignored. is never good because it breaks the integrity of the service. vote manipulation is called hustling these days. it tends to be okay if you're in the blessed class allowed to manipulate people or are doing it for a good cause (a private for-profit startup needing "exposure"). They delight in breaking rules, but not rules that matter. http://www.paulgraham.com/founders.html http://www.paulgraham.com/founders.html
- sobkas 11y ago>it is never good because it breaks the integrity of the service. So you are trying to imply that HN(or any other link aggregator) have integrity?
- austenallred 11y agoI think the problem is how easy it is to game HN, how effective it is to game HN, and how random and spurious it is if you don't game HN. It's really difficult to just have your post get to the front page organically. It's possible (and probable) that when you submit there just aren't enough people looking at the /new page, so a lot of it comes down to sheer luck. A lot of good/great posts go by unnoticed. Getting 1 or 2 friends to upvote would probably increase your likelihood of being on the front page by 90%. I've been gravitating towards things like http://lpushx.com http://lpushx.com, both because they're smaller, and because everything has more of a chance to "survive." Ironically, this post just exposes how helpful it is to do the behavior it discourages. When you're trying to kill a lucrative behavior (especially something that exposes a loophole), saying, "Please don't do this behavior" is probably the worst way to do so. Now several people just figured out that you can game the system. I would recommend dang kill this.
- andybak 11y agoThis just occurred to me and I'm sure it's probably already been considered. The home page should have display a sidebar or similar with the top 5 or so 'new' items. They then have a chance to catch someone's eye and get voted up to the 'real' front page. I'd love to spend more time on 'new' - I just tend to forget about it. Something that improved the visibility of new items would help me (..help HN)
- drdeca 11y agoI agree that something like this could be good. Maybe instead of a sidebar, it could have them interspersed throughout the page? (possibly with the additional requirement that they wouldn't already be on the front page)
- jsnell 11y agoThe average post in /newest is so bad that it's not clear you want to promote any of them to the frontpage randomly. I'd guess on average on a 30 item page of /newest I might click through two links, and upvote one. I actually wonder if the stats in this post can possibly be correct. Never would have guessed that anywhere near 10-20% of the submissions hit 10 points. There's a lot of spam and offtopic stuff, and it is indeed really common for great posts to get lost in the noise with just a couple of votes.
- notacoward 11y ago> While blatant voting manipulation may be the status quo at a certain other startup-oriented link aggregator As I was recently told... > No acerbic swipes on Hacker News, please. Let's try to avoid double standards, OK?
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoI love the irony of this post.
- stefantalpalaru 11y agoSure, don't worry about wasting your time submitting links that have a 80-90% chance of being ignored. Do what I do and, once you manage to get enough karma points to no longer care about them, simply stop trying to contribute. There's always lobste.rs for when you really want to share something with your peers.
- chilicuil 11y agolobste.rs is only accessible through invitation, can you send me one?, echo bUBqYXZpZXIuaW8K | base64 -d
- stefantalpalaru 11y agoInvitation sent. I don't know when they disabled the form to ask for an invitation. I used that more than a year ago when I joined. Maybe it's the curse of any online community to get shittier as the time passes...
- dragandj 11y agoStefan, would you please send me an invite to lobste.rs?
- kemiller 11y agoWe've seen some legitimate posts consistently reported and removed. There are definitely fishy dynamics.
- tptacek 11y agoThe stuff they do to detect voting rings is broader than you might expect, so if you're submitting things and having them fail, consider not telling your friends about it.
- onion2k 11y agoIt's worth noting that there are two sorts of posts that people will try to game the voting process - submissions by people who want the status of higher karma among their peers and submissions by startup founders who want "traction"[1]. That is to say, people believe there is actual, real tangible value in getting upvotes. To that end, while it'd be nice for HN to be more organic, unless there's a penalty for gaming the system it's not going stop just because people ask nicely. [1] The traction you get on a site like HN is useful for feedback but it probably won't covert to sales unless you building something for other startups. It's not real take-it-to-the-investors traction.
- shubhamjain 11y agoI would point out that, getting karma using submission isn't that hard. Considering that Hacker News is very tolerant to re-submissions, you can usually land your submission to front page, posting some of the many awesome articles that you might have read from here. Some of the articles have been posted dozens of times, yet they articulate interesting discussion, even after being posted nth-time.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoTrue, but there are two distinct cases. 1. You post something awesome that you saw on HN that didn't get any traction. This we encourage! It's a kind of community service and deserves karma, though arguably the original submitter should share some. 2. You post something that has had significant attention on HN already. This is ok, but only for the very best stories and only after a year or so (cf. the FAQ linked at the bottom of the page).
- shubhamjain 11y agoDoes HN penalize submission violating the second point?
- hardwaresofton 11y agoI always try and 'remember to upvote'. So much great content goes through here, I think many members forget to upvote things they thought were interesting. I often forget to hit upvote on an article I clicked through to and read/enjoyed. Might lead to upvote inflation but I think extra positivity isn't a terrible problem to have.
- mbrutsch 11y agoNo worries, it's just not worth it to post on HN.
- rndn 11y agoIdea for a fix: Perhaps HN should have separate karma to reward upvoting on /new on links that are successful later, much like reddit used to have (or still has?) trophies for correctly predicting that a link reaches the frontpage. If there is more incentive to vote on new items you get more accurate estimates of the link quality, and it also does warrant reward to sift through lists with such a low SNR.
- edpichler 11y agoDespite all of these problems, I always have a good reading here on HN.
- bosdev 11y agoThe issue isn't that content rises which isn't good, it's that good content doesn't rise. So there might be 3x more good stuff getting posted than actually makes it onto the frontpage.
- zackbloom 11y agoI can say from personal experience that it is much easier to get on the frontpage if you have a group of four or five people ready to upvote your content. It is possible to get a post to rise without that, but it often takes a handful of reposts. I believe the crux of this issue is not enough people frequent the new page (https://news.ycombinator.com/newest https://news.ycombinator.com/newest). If that page got enough traffic, the legitimate votes would outweigh all but the most systematic attempts to 'game' the system.
- msl09 11y agoI can speak for myself that I often forget that the new page exist.
- protomyth 11y agoI have better luck getting upvoted on weekends or as a side article to a topic-of-the-day, but I tend to submit articles that are either directly computer related or about systems that are not going as planned.
- geofft 11y ago> While blatant voting manipulation may be the status quo at a certain other startup-oriented link aggregator, it is never good because it breaks the integrity of the service. Why does it break the integrity of the service? Sockpuppets, sure, but why does asking friends/acquaintances with established HN accounts (presumably the HN software can distinguish these cases) for upvotes work contrary to the goals? Presumably if you have an account and you "vote well" -- that is, your upvotes are well-correlated with what other people upvote and don't downvote -- you know what people like to see. If a friend asked me to upvote their spam listicle, or a question they could just ask me and get an answer, or some politics story irrelevant to hackerdom, I'd say no. If I "manipulate" a friend's post, I'm making as much of an endorsement of the content as HN-appropriate as if I upvoted something I saw on the front page. (And if I abuse that, my upvotes should get disregarded.) To be clear, I'm not advocating that bugging your friends for upvotes is a good system. I am advocating that posters asking people who care about HN for endorsement is explicitly desirable, and the software and community norms should be designed to reflect this, instead of the community norm deciding that vote manipulation is an acceptable means to an otherwise-technically-unsupported end.