8 ms·
Google Glass never died. I don't understand how people come to this conclusion when they're also aware that it was handed off to Tony Fadell of the Nest divisio
by chaostheory 11y ago
Google Glass never died. I don't understand how people come to this conclusion when they're also aware that it was handed off to Tony Fadell of the Nest division to manage.
Going on a tangent, to this day I fail to understand why Apple didn't even make a bid on Nest. At the very least it would keep someone with both good taste and a strong enough force of personality to make it happen, away from Google's hands. Instead Apple spends over twice as much on Beats... Did Fadell hate his tenure at Apple so much that he wouldn't even consider a bid from them or vice versa?
- jinushaun 11y agoAgree. Nest belongs at Apple, not Google. Apple could've owned the home with AppleTV, Nest and HomeKit.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoApple doesn't bother with experiences unless they are a big part of most peoples' days. Fiddling with your thermostat is not a huge part of most peoples' days. Nest has yet to prove that they can make a product that plays a significant role in our lives. Beats has. People wear Beats all day.
- chaostheory 11y agoIf that's the case, then why is Apple bothering with Homekit? Nest isn't just about thermostats and fire alarms. Nest is going to encompass your whole house which is the same thing that Homekit aspires to do. I still feel that Apple made a huge mistake by letting Nest go to Google. The main difference between Homekit and Nest is that Nest's products and platform has already been battle tested.
- Steko 11y agoNot to denigrate Nest but I don't think not having them is going to make Apple any less formidable in the home. Nest's competence is design sense/simple ux which Apple already has plenty of but Google doesn't. That makes them far more valuable to Google. Like just imagine a Nest-less world where Google and Apple both release smart thermostats in 2010. The Apple product might look like Nest and the Google one would prolly look like whatever Honeywell was selling at the time.
- andybak 11y ago> Nest's competence is design sense/simple ux which Apple already has plenty of but Google doesn't. I think this trope is rather out of date. If you look at Inbox, Google Play Music, Keep and a few other Google properties, it's not implausible to argue they are ahead of many Apple products.
- Steko 11y agoStrange that you go right to Inbox as an example because, like Nest, it was the result of an expensive acquisition of a noted design team. Which just supports my point, that design isn't a core competence at Google. Are they improving? Sure. But, back to devices and Glass itself, Glass sticking out like a sore thumb, users being branded assholes and banned from use all over is an obvious example of just flat out design incompetence. https://twitter.com/jm_denis/status/524968589489479680 https://twitter.com/jm_denis/status/524968589489479680
- andybak 11y agoIsn't there a slight fallacy at the heart of your stance? You seem to be positing an innate, unchangeable taint that can never be eradicated by change - no matter how pervasive that shift becomes.
- Steko 11y agoNo I'm positing that this one particular characteristic not only hasn't been completely eradicated yet, but I don't think they're even trying to eradicate it (although they are trying to mitigate it). Fundamentally Apple is still a company run by designers and Google is still a company run by engineering and yes companies can change what they are fundamentally about but no I don't see either of these two have done this. If anything, I see it being reinforced, with this being personified with moves like Jony Ive taking over Forstall's duties and Melissa Mayer needing to leave Google. I don't like the term you've chosen here, "taint" because Google's culture and hiring preferences have certainly paid off for them in other ways.
- 11y ago
- Steko 11y ago> Instead Apple spends over twice as much on Beats. According to wikipedia both acquisitions were $3.2 billion. Beats revenue was 5 times Nest's though.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoNot to mention that it enabled them to quickly put together a good streaming service which has been highly praised so far (complaints all seem to centre on UI complexity, not the service itself). And if that didn't work out at least Beats makes enough revenue to earn back it's acquisition cost in a few years - Nest would've been a much bigger gamble.
- chaostheory 11y agoI don't feel Nest would be a gamble since Apple is also aiming to automate homes. At the very least, they keep good talent away from Google and have a mature platform to build on like what happened with NeXT and OSX.
- lnanek2 11y agoIt's dead as a door nail to any owner who wants an update after paying $1500. It's dead for any developer who wants to write a consumer app since consumers can't buy them. It's dead for any startup that wants investment to write something consumer facing. B2B, well, there already are HMDs for B2B, so Google isn't really bringing anything innovative there. Hell, there are already HMDs made for specific uses like firemen and policemen vs. HMDs made for other things, so Google can't even beat all of them with one product. After the poor support the original received, I can't really in good conscience even recommend a company go with Google, although I admit TI end of life-ing the OMAP and firing everyone didn't leave them much choice. I've worked on OMAP solutions after that and it is a nightmare, the only solution often being hiring an expensive consultancy that has some of the original employees who know things the manuals are light on.
- stickfigure 11y agoThis is not really a fair characterization. Glass was "dead" as a consumer product even before it was released. I'm old enough to remember the blowback that the first generation of cellphone users got ("coke-snorting 80s douchebags"). I remember people explaining how they didn't want to be reachable. It took a while for cellphones to seep into our collective consciousness, and glass will be the same. After glass gains acceptance as a work tool, it will creep back into the consumer space. And people that threw around the term "glassholes" are going to look shortsighted and pathetic in retrospect.
- thaumaturgy 11y agoI'm in my late thirties and was among the first generation of daily cell phone owners once the bulky bricks were replaced by flip phones. I don't recall the same reactions that you do. There are still a lot of people who don't own or regularly use a cell phone and others who prefer not to be reachable all the time, that hasn't really changed. Glass's popularity in the consumer market at some point in the possible future will hinge on whatever conversation a future generation has about the expectations of privacy in public spaces. Until that conversation happens, Glass isn't really viable as a consumer product.
- shultays 11y agoGoogle Glass never died Yeah, it should born first.