4 ms·
Thank you for this great comment. > In both cases you're affecting the exact same thing and, if you like, it would be fair to analyze it as a monad. Perhaps,
by pron 11y ago
Thank you for this great comment.
> In both cases you're affecting the exact same thing and, if you like, it would be fair to analyze it as a monad.
Perhaps, but here's the thing -- I don't care. In fact, I am truly and utterly sorry for having taken the time to understand what monads are -- sort of (well, not really, but you get what I mean). I consider it a waste of time that could have been better spent reading another DB or concurrency paper (my current fields of work). As a veteran programmer in the industry (almost twenty years) I really don't care much about programming language concepts or verification methods (I am interested in compilers, especially Graal, which I think is a great breakthrough, but that's a completely different matter). I want to write an algorithm in a way that is straightforward, easily communicable with my colleagues and successors, be able to read and understand other's code, and be able to reason about it both before as well as after it runs. With the recent resurgence of PFP and it's (IMO, sometimes unfortunate) influence on imperative languages, I find this emphasis on expression and abstraction very distracting. When programming in a "richly typed" myself, I often find myself drawn to using clever abstractions that are necessary neither for expressing the algorithm nor for making the code more maintainable or readable, which is why I enjoy using languages with relatively few abstractions (C, Java, Go). I find expressing the algorithm much more straightforward, faster (because I don't waste time coming out with a nifty abstraction and then being pleased with myself about it), and not a bit less readable. Ever since I started using automated tests (along with the rest of the industry) I've never even found correctness to be a problem.
Which leads me to ask, what problem is PFP trying to solve? Now, I am entirely willing to believe that it's not trying to solve an acute crisis, but just to make programming "better" (which hopefully means cheaper). But if that is the case, I have been waiting for convincing evidence for the past 16 or so years -- ever since first hearing of Haskell and its imminent revolution at university -- and so far: nothing. I am not saying that PFP is necessarily a false prophet (although I still think imperative code with even crude effect systems is just as effective, and much clearer than PFP -- and no, I don't think they're the same at all even if they could be both reduced to each other: I am not a PL researcher, nor do I personally care to know much about that CS sub-discipline; from the perspective of the programmer the two are completely different), but I do see it as something of a vaporware. A lot of hype and no result. That the largest Haskell program -- after twenty years -- is the Haskell compiler is a very bad signal (and yes, it is the biggest program).
As for mathematics and the human mind, well, I think the search space is just too big on both ends. Math can express just about anything (including, probably, types of intelligence very different from the human mind), and the human mind is very flexible, a universal computer, which, in spite of its many constraints, is probably universal enough to not be meaningfully reducible to its physical components (just as software is not meaningfully reducible to the physical processes powering the hardware it runs on). So I don't really know if the human mind or math can converge to anything, other than that our mathematical exploration is guided by our human minds, so we might be subconsciously heading somewhere interesting.
- tel 11y agoIt's late, so while I'd like to bite more, I'll just take this one on: > other than that our mathematical exploration is guided by our human minds I think that's exactly it. I'm not honestly a good enough philosopher to be clear on how I feel about the origins of mathematics. So, blurrily, I'll just state immediately that I think they are an embodied thing (I am no Platonic dualist). In that sense they are not constrained by our language but instead our language is continually growing to be so strong as to admit the vagaries of our thoughts. And this is why I like PFP: because it endeavors to capture a wider world than just algorithms—although it is one which places algorithm at its core by accepting the need to build and witness over placing trust in the completeness of the universe. This justification is wildly impractical, of course. I can't even from this perspective recognize the smell of practical—so the closest I can come is to say that I think Church's Thesis, if it is even true, taught us something really interesting: that it's quite easy to represent all functions (nat -> nat). Since this encompasses nearly everything we can "practically" witness we're playing in a giant, easy sandbox (this is not me saying that programming is easy, of course!). So there ends up being a lot of degrees of freedom on how we accomplish our giant, easy tasks. If you want to eliminate them then you must take aim at harder tasks---and that is exactly what PFP does do. Or at least what the research apparatus attached to PFP does. So out here is a wild ride to the core of human expression. That's one that I want to ride.
- pron 11y ago> and that is exactly what PFP does do True, but 1/ with so far very little to show for it (it is easy to make easy programs easy; no one has seen PFP make hard programs easier) and 2/ I am far from convinced (although I haven't explored other avenues myself, as PL is not my field) that there aren't other approaches which do the same and are more compatible with how we think. I think that other than the happy "coincidence" that is Curry-Howard, I see nothing in LC to suggest that it is the "right" way to model computation, and CH itself is just a form of verification (that requires programmers to prove their programs). Maybe it's the right way to do verification and maybe it isn't. Suppose Hoare logic approaches proved to be easy. Would people still see LC as promising? I think it's seen as promising just because verification is easier -- not because there is evidence to suggest it's the right way to express unverified algorithms -- but nobody has quantified the cost/benefit of various verification techniques (both formal and informal). Other than the mathematical results which are to be expected to be found under this powerful lamppost, I see little evidence to suggest PFP is even on the right track. PFP has had one obvious achievement, though: thanks to PFP, there's a lot of research into type systems, some may prove to be very useful even in imperative languages (like Rust, although that language is also far from being proven, either, but I have a feeling we'll learn of its effectiveness -- or lack thereof -- much sooner than we will of Haskell's :)) But I find that achievement rather disappointing compared to those of the algorithmic CS disciplines (distributed databases, machine learning, JITs). I do recognize that PL has a much harder time proving the worth of its results. A machine learning algorithm could be implemented in any language. Producing and then getting people to adopt a new language, in contrast, is extremely expensive, as it requires not only implementing the new work, but porting man-decades of work. But sympathy aside, as someone in the industry, I view PL research as that CS discipline that's supposed to concentrate most on the human side, yet contributed least to to our industry's achievements (while making more noise than most other CS disciplines). And this is where I'd like to circle back to the original post and the discussion of whether PFP people are arrogant or not. I don't know too many PFP people with major achievements in the industry, but I don't suppose they are any more or less arrogant than others. I do, however, find it annoying (and ridiculous) to be accused by some PLers of having an anti-intellectual stance or refusal to try new things simply because I'm very skeptical of new languages. I and others like me are very quick to adopt new algorithms, but new languages are not only extremely costly to adopt -- they have so far delivered precious little more than big promises (but oh, do they love making those promises!). So if I were to describe PL researchers and PFPers in particular, I'd say they overpromise and under-deliver more than the rest of academic CS, and have certainly had the least impact on the industry. I can suggest (with little knowledge of actual facts) that the reason for that is that PL, as a UX discipline, should be most accommodating to human psychology, but in practice it is often as uncompromising as any other pure-theoretical field.