3 ms·
What about PHP, though? The crappiest, least abstracting language seems to be the most productive one. Perhaps abstractions really are just bullshit? I like abs
by Tichy 19y ago
What about PHP, though? The crappiest, least abstracting language seems to be the most productive one. Perhaps abstractions really are just bullshit? I like abstractions, but while I am busy thinking about my abstractions, the PHP coder has already churned out another three no-brainer pages.
- icky 19y agoThere's the rub: measuring production time needs to take into account maintenance time!
- Tichy 19y agoNevertheless, PHP seems to be by far the most successful programming language for web applications. I also don't think that maintenance time was ever measured for typical production time studies.
- brlewis 19y agoThat's like saying falling on the ice is by far the most successful ice-skating technique.
- lazyant 19y agosuccessful != popular ?
- Tichy 19y agoMost of the recently hyped web applications are written in PHP, for example Facebook. Wasn't there a list recently with the 10 most successful startups (by whatever criterion), and 7 out of 10 were based on PHP?
- mechanical_fish 19y agoThat's not because PHP is especially great, today, but because there weren't any decent alternatives in 2004. Rails is three-and-a-half years old, as a public project. The alternative frameworks are about the same age. There are programmers with ten years of PHP experience; there is nobody on Earth with so much as three years of Django experience. Give the newbs some time to settle in before you declare PHP's long-term victory. PHP has had a long headstart. To have a successful startup that makes a 2007 list, you have to start learning programming before 2007. Back in 2003, PHP was pretty much the name of the game, unless you enjoyed being married to Microsoft or wanted to construct vast mountains of overdesigned, stateful, undeployable Java middleware. Or unless you were writing your own framework from scratch in an alternative language, like DHH, or the Django folks, or the Redditers.
- reitzensteinm 19y agoWell PHP was written by someone, too, and that improved productivity over what came before (CGI/C++?). Django and Rails aren't really central to my argument - they can be replaced with any language/library/framework that boosts productivity. Careful about saying 'least abstracting' though - if it really is faster (not my experience, but assuming it is), then although it might not appear to be a powerful abstraction, it actually is, at least in some way. Your abstractions (done well) are exactly what I'm talking about - long term productivity. Given 100 minutes you may well be well behind (if you've even started actually coding), but will that still be true 100 days later if the other guy is writing it in straight, hackish PHP?