3 ms·
That would only solve the problem of not penalizing existing retirees. It would force all people currently saving for retirement to save 10-15% more to pay thi
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
That would only solve the problem of not penalizing existing retirees. It would force all people currently saving for retirement to save 10-15% more to pay this new pile of tax. And what, precisely, do they get in return for that added tax burden?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> And what, precisely, do they get in return for that added tax burden? They get the relative burden of taxation shifted off the of other sources of income, including the source they are using to get money to pay for retirement. (The specific effect depends on how that relative shift is used.) In any case, if the current favorable treatment of capital is inequitable, there is no entitlement for people to expect it to continue going forward.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoAlternatively, if the goal here is to stop hedge funds from taking advantage of long-term capital gains, perhaps it would make more sense to cap the amount of gains exempted as long-term and make the rest short-term. Set a cap well above what the vast majority of individuals would hit, and below what any aggregate fund would hit. For instance, "long-term capital gains can only be applied to the first $150k of gains per year; gains above that are always taxed at the short-term rate". > They get the relative burden of taxation shifted off the of other sources of income, including the source they are using to get money to pay for retirement. (The specific effect depends on how that relative shift is used.) You say that as though an increase in taxes here will be used to decrease taxes elsewhere. That does not match the reality of changes to tax law; tax revenue will simply increase, with no changes to taxes elsewhere. > In any case, if the current favorable treatment of capital is inequitable, there is no entitlement for people to expect it to continue going forward. There is no entitlement for government to apply arbitrary taxes and expect people to bear it, either, without providing a commensurate improvement in value.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> It would force all people currently saving for retirement to save 10-15% more to pay this new pile of tax. This will happen regardless, as tax rates have nowhere to go but up in the USA (considering trillions in unfunded liabilities). > And what, precisely, do they get in return for that added tax burden? Civilization. That's exactly what taxes pay for.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> This will happen regardless, as tax rates have nowhere to go but up in the USA (considering trillions in unfunded liabilities). Because when you've run up a giant pile of debt, the response should be "get and spend more money" rather than "spend less"? > Civilization. That's exactly what taxes pay for. As long as we're being snarky: product not as advertised, cost inflated well over initial agreement, return policy non-existent and no refund available. Would refuse to do business with again if not for geographic monopoly and coercion.
- Frondo 11y agoSo get involved with the political process and work to make it better. It's so easy to get into local and state politics, and that's the stuff that has the biggest influence over your life. I don't get why more people don't do this!
- JoshTriplett 11y agoGetting involved with politics is a life-consuming activity, especially if you want to actually change anything. My state, unlike most in the US and unlike the US federal government, at least has a requirement that all tax issues must be voted on by the general public rather than just passed by the legislature and signed by the governor. The federal government, however, is the largest source of both taxes and onerous regulations, the most challenging and time-consuming to get involved with, and the most resistant to change. (This is, oddly, a larger-scale version of the same problem Wikipedia has or many other organizations have: whoever has the most time to waste can be the most successful creating and thriving in a bureaucracy, winning by sheer volume rather than by merit. Or, alternatively: anyone who would want the job shouldn't have it, and anyone who should have the job wouldn't want it.)